Deadspin Has No Idea How to Make a Cheesesteak

Please don’t follow this recipe.

Screen Shot 2014-01-14 at 12.54.30 PM

What’s wrong with this picture?

Over the weekend, Deadspin “Foodspin” writer Albert Burneko published a piece called: “How to Make a Cheesesteak and Probably Get Crap from Pennsylvanians.” Probably?

Burneko anticipated some of the criticism his terrible recipe (just wait, it’s coming) would inevitably engender. So he wrote this: “It’s a steak sandwich. There’s nothing in it that can’t be found or made damn near anywhere else in the United States, nor any particular culinary discipline or technique unique to Philadelphia that makes its cheesesteaks special.”

Mr. Burneko (can I call you that?) is correct that there is no citywide “discipline” or “technique” that renders the local cheesesteak superior to non-Philadelphia cheesesteaks. (There are, of course, cheesesteak places that make meaner cheesesteaks than others, for the same reasons some restaurants make better burgers than others. But I digress.) What he fails to realize is that there are very specific ingredients that one must use when constructing a proper cheesesteak. Because the ones he chooses would result in a disastrous, disgusting, nuclear leak of a sandwich.


Steak (Ok, we’re with you.)

Italian roll (Sure.)

2 slices of provolone (Great. Except–2 slices? No. More.)

Onions, chopped, sauteed (Awesome.)

Peppers, chopped, sauteed (Hots, maybe. Not regular bell peppers, though. C’mon. Don’t need that watery stuff in there.)

Mayonnaise, slathered on roll (What the hell?)

Lettuce (……)

For those who actually follow Foodspin recipes, read closely: All you need is sliced ribeye, diced, sauteed onions, and provolone. (And even onions are optional if you’re convinced that the rest of your ingredients are of the highest quality.) Copious amounts of all of it, maybe with a hot pepper on the side. You’d think the ghost of A.J. Daulerio would have stepped in to intervene at some point…

Around The Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • Theophrastus von Hohenheim

    I’m sorry, but American cheese is a better cheese to use in a cheesesteak than provolone. Provolone doesn’t melt well. Whiz also works.

  • Coleen McCrea Katz

    Mayonnaise? MAYONNAISE???

  • MystiKasT

    You wouldn’t use provolone on a cheesesteak, the hell is wrong with you?

  • Objective Reader

    There’s a difference between a “terrible” recipe and a recipe that’s just different from what you know.

  • Denise Rambo

    The BIGGEST reason cheesesteaks outside the Philadelphia area suck is that they can’t get decent rolls.

  • Boo-urns

    Why does everyone outside of Philly seem to think that a Philly cheesesteak gets green (or red) peppers? Where did this fallacy start???