Feature: Barbecue in Philly Bars

Step aside, burgers. There’s a new bar trend in town.

A guy walks into an Irish pub and orders … West Carolina hickory-smoked, hand-pulled-and-chopped pork barbecue and smoked brisket with a side of collards.

It’s no joke: Fergie’s, the Sansom Street saloon, has added a slew of Southern fare to its traditional Irish menu. And it’s not the only Philly spot to make the switch: Old City’s long-running rock ’n’ roll club the Khyber Pass has abandoned Fenders in favor of fried chicken, and Queen Village’s Catahoula (formerly Sauté) chucked its Continental cuisine for Creole/Cajun dishes like gumbo. What’s behind this sudden desire for Dixie grub?

There are the usual explanations — comfort food is popular in a down economy; it’s trendy in New York — but mostly, it seems, our dining scene abhors a vacuum. “Southern food is one of those things people in Philly lament, like good bagels,”
says Khyber co-owner Stephen Simons.

“It’s not that readily available.”

At Fergie’s, it was a serendipitous encounter between owner Fergus Carey and Mississippi native Mark Coates, chef-owner of now-defunct Bebe’s BBQ in the Italian Market, that led to the Irish-Southern mash-up. “Mark was looking for a space, and I loved his food at Bebe’s,” Carey says. “We were refreshing Fergie’s anyway, so I thought, ‘Irish and barbecue — why not?’”

Authenticity is paramount to Southern-food fans — so how do these Yankee spots stack up? “I originally opened Bebe’s because I couldn’t find anything in Philly that tasted like home,” says Coates in a thick-as-honey drawl. “It’s simple food. You start to try to be creative, and that’s not Southern food.”

Khyber co-owner Dave Frank takes a more pragmatic approach: “We’re never going to get ‘authentic’; it’s the basis, not a re-creation. The brisket is Texas-ish. We understand it’s not going to be the same.” But he and Simons are making the effort: The po’boy loaves are shipped up from New Orleans’ Leidenheimer Baking Company, which, Frank says, “is the equivalent of opening a hoagie shop in New Orleans and having Sarcone’s delivered.”

Around the Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.