Best of Philly

Best Thrift Store

2026 Best Thrift Store

The Garb Collection

Caitlin Quirk, owner of South Jersey retailer The Garb Collection, is reimagining the secondhand shopping experience with a rental closet concept that puts sellers in control. A $25 online deposit secures a rack in the store for up to 80 items for 10 to 30 days. Sellers set their own prices (the staff will help) and can track sales in real time. Looking to buy? Coveted brands like Theory, Farm Rio, and Lilly Pulitzer have been spied at the Collingswood location. Read More »

Locations in Collingswood and Ocean City, NJ Website

2022 Best Thrift Shop, 'Burbs

Habitat for Humanity Restore

Would you be surprised if we told you that some well-known Philadelphians can be found scavenging for cast-off decor treasures at the new Warminster warehouse? Whether you’re intent on saving the planet or your wallet, ReStore’s blink-and-you’ll-miss-it selection of new and gently used furnishings is diverse and eclectic. A single shopping haul could yield a low-slung velvet couch, a Sub-Zero stainless steel refrigerator, and enough decorative baskets to populate Pinterest. Read More »

539 Jacksonville Road, Warminster, PA Website

2020 Best Thrift Shop for Irreverent Tees

Big Top Thrift

Even if Big Top didn’t have a huge charitable aspect — which it does — we’d still want to shop here for the many lighthearted and fun finds (cowboy boots, kitschy kitchen goods). But winking tees are definitely the centerpiece: Garfield, Hard Rock Osaka, Mrs. T’s Pierogies and Uncle Fester are only a few examples. Claim yours by sending a DM through Instagram. @bigtopthrift. Read More »

Website