Jim Kenney’s Long War with the Archdiocese

The mayoral nominee is a disaffected Catholic disgusted by local church leadership.


Charles Chaput and Jim Kenney. | Photos by Jeff Fusco.

Democratic mayoral nominee Jim Kenney is a proud graduate of St. Joe’s Prep and La Salle. He was born and raised in a Irish Catholic family. He is the single most devoted fan of the Neuman-Goretti women’s basketball team in the world.

And yet, Kenney’s relationship with the Catholic Church is fraught. Actually, the more accurate adjective is probably just “hostile.” Kenney showed vividly just how little regard he has for local church leaders on Thursday, when he waded into the debate over the abrupt firing of a beloved, gay faculty member at Waldron Mercy Academy in Merion. In an Inquirer story, Kenney accused “cowardly men” in the Archdiocese of Philadelphia of orchestrating the firing. “If you’re a church official and you feel that strongly that this woman and her partner are such a threat to society, stand up and say so,” Kenney told the paper.

That might seem like extraordinarily blunt language coming from the likely next mayor of the city and aimed not-so-subtly at Archbishop Charles J. Chaput. But it’s actually not all that different from Kenney’s past public statements about the archdiocese. Like the time he urged Pope Francis to “kick some ass” in the archdiocese.

Kenney began feuding with the archdioceses as far back as 1998, when Catholic leaders mobilized to block a City Council bill granting benefits to partners of gay city employees that Kenney co-sponsored. More recently, he’s sparred with archdiocesan leadership over the closing of parochial schools, publicly criticized their decision to ban an 11-year-old girl from playing CYO football and wished out-loud that Pope Francis will straighten out Chaput and company when he comes to town in September.

In a lot of respects, of course, Kenney’s fight with the archdiocese is just a microcosm of the broader debate playing out in the Catholic community. Church conservatives, like Chaput, are digging in, even as the broader culture embraces marriage equality. Liberal catholics, like Kenney (and a lot of other Philadelphia catholics), desperately want the church to change with the times, not just on gay marriage, but on the role of women and a host of other issues. The ascension of liberal Pope Francis has raised the stakes of the debate. And now the liberal Francis is coming to Philadelphia, where he’ll be hosted by the very-conservative Chaput, all while Kenney (who can summon dozens of news cameras and microphones whenever he likes) looks on….

The World Meeting of Families doesn’t look like it’ll be boring. But let’s not get ahead of ourselves.

Does this latest episode hurt Kenney at all? Might he have alienated true-blue city Catholics with his criticism? It’s certainly possible that it will, but it’s also likely to further enhance Kenney’s standing in progressive circles and among gay voters.

The harder question is this: should a mayor speak so bluntly on such charged issues? Or is it unbecoming of the office to weigh in so strongly so quickly? This is a controversy about a school outside city limits, after all. Mayor Nutter hasn’t issued any press releases.

There’s no simple answer to that one. Mayors do need to exercise more discretion than Council members. Mayors are emissaries for the whole city, and Philadelphia is a complicated place that’s home to people with a lot of different beliefs.

But for Kenney, justice is justice, and a wrong is a wrong. He doesn’t take a black-and-white approach to everything. But on certain matters — like gay equality, like gender equality — Kenney is a moral absolutist, and he’s not going mince words or avoid fights, even if he does become mayor. Lauren Hitt, Kenney’s communications director, told me a while back in a conversation about a completely different topic that he “has an annoyingly strong moral compass.” Right now, Kenney’s moral compass is the pointing in the polar opposite direction of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia. And in recent years, Kenney has been his most convincing — and his popular appeal has been strongest — when he has framed his policy preferences in stark moral terms.

We just put in a request with Kenney’s campaign to talk to him about his faith and his relationship with the Catholic church, and if he’s got time for an interview we’ll bring you his answers in depth.

But Kenney being Kenney, a lot of his feelings are already out there on Twitter. See below.

Follow @pkerkstra and @CitifiedPHL on Twitter.

Around The Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • Elyss

    I’m still don’t understand how this myth that the pope is liberal persists. What in the Catholic church has actually changed regarding homosexuality, women, birth control, turning pædophile priests over to the police etc etc? Nothing at all, that’s what. He’s a good PR man, that’s all, and as fundamentally conservative as his predecessor. He’s nothing more than an opportunistic hypocrite.

  • Kathy11

    Kenney would seem to be where the majority of Catholics are – disagreeing with the conservatives in the hierarchy:

    “Among the U.S. Catholics surveyed by Saint Leo University Polling Institute:

    Sixty-eight percent favor allowing divorced or remarried Catholics
    to receive the sacrament of Communion, even if their previous marriages
    have not been annulled. Only 18 percent do not.

    Sixty-six percent of Catholics say the Church should drop its opposition to contraception while only 21 percent do not.

    A smaller majority of U.S. Catholics (50 to 33 percent) supports dropping opposition to pre-marital sex and cohabitation.

    A narrow plurality (42 to 40 percent) says the Church should recognize same-sex marriages.

    Pope Francis has approval numbers that Washington politicians can
    only dream about. Among the U.S. Catholics polled, 85 percent gave him a
    favorable rating.”

    Archbishop Chaput is the one outside the mainstream of even Catholic thought today. He’s one of the most conservative clerics in the church and doesn’t hesitate to tell parishioners how to vote – as he did with Kerry and Obama. So – what’s good for the goose. Hey – I didn’t vote for him.

    • Kathy11

      It’s also worth noting that criticizing the church hierarchy has a rather long and respectable heritage among Irish Catholics – particularly those trained by the Jesuits. Those without that intellectual background carry many of the same sentiments – though they don’t take kindly to outsiders stating such things. As is the norm for most groups.

      “In the opening line of James Joyce’s Ulysses , stately,
      plump Buck Mulligan bears “a bowl of lather on which a mirror and a razor lay
      crossed.” Holding the bowl aloft he declares, “ Introibo ad altare Dei. ”
      Mulligan, in this symbolic action, expresses Joyce’s critique of Christianity:
      a combination of sadism, the razor, and narcissism, the mirror.”

      Criticism of the church’s actions that affect people is an Irish tradition.

      “There is no heresy or no philosophy which is so abhorrent
      to the church as a human being.” – James Joyce

      • murdog

        another glass of kool aid please

        • Kathy11

          yes, kool aid is associated with religion. but I don’t think Rev Jones was Catholic.

  • Copper34

    I’m rooting for Kenney.

  • http://batman-news.com PPABootsquadVinnie

    There is no god. I’ll believe if you can Prove it to me. Don’t say ‘Take it on faith’, I’d like a Rational explanation please.
    Love George Carlin’s riff on god as this great ‘invisible man’ controlling everything.
    Why is it nowadays if someone says they spoke to god you’d call him crazy?
    No GOD, No Allah, No whatever. Maybe a great Spirit……..

  • Earl J

    Strong, well researched read.

  • Kevin Burns

    More reasons to admire Jim Kenney. He is honest and direct. Well done!

    • murdog

      Also a A Hole, if you like the mayor of NY you will love Kenny. I wouldnot let Kenny run my kool aid stand let alone a city but I guess you liberal lap dogs love him.