The Great Philadelphia Pizza Quest

One thousand pizzas, five hundred restaurants, 50 favorites: the best of the best (of the best)

The idea sounded so simple. Why not do a real survey of the pizza available in Philadelphia? Why not call out the best pizzas by name—but only after we knew which were truly the best by eating, well, all of them? Or at least all that we reasonably could—damning the expense, all reasonable restraint and the wise concerns of our tailors and loved ones. Judging food is such a subjective thing, but this one time, we’d get as close to the truth as we could by doing something that no one had tried before: simply eating until we popped.  

That was the idea. What you hold in your hands is the result: an account of the 50 best pizzas (in five different categories) to be had anywhere from the shadow of the Limerick Power Plant to the wilds of South Jersey. By the time we were finished, we’d visited 500 pizza places and eaten more than a thousand pizzas. We’d covered two states and more neighborhoods than can be counted. And while you’d think that all those pies would’ve turned us off forever from the charms of the brick-oven masterpiece or the street-corner slice, you’d be wrong. After taking a breath, pausing to look over our good works and resting a bit in the sure knowledge of a job well and completely done, you know what we all kinda wanted more than anything?
Just one more slice.

Edited by Jason Sheehan and Janine White

Around The Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • Joanne

    I work in the Spring Mill Building in Conshohocken and there is a guy who makes awesome pizza! Every pizza he makes is memorable! He’s notably passionate about what he does. It’s no fault to your staff that you missed visiting this place because he’s modest and doesn’t like to promote himself through media. He believes in word of mouth success. All customers that make their way over to his side of the cafe noticably rave about it after they finish the whole slice. The crust is incredible, like I never experienced before. Most of his signature pizzas are his own creations and can only be eaten there. If you’re ever in the area stop by and indulge in the experience. You won’t be disappointed. Go unannounced and order a slice. I’m not getting compensation for this or a staff member. I’m simply reaching out to truly give him the recognition he deserves. If you need to justify it simply ask any random person in a million square feet of office in the Spring Mill corporate complex and they will undoubtfully make that claim.

  • lotsaletters

    How can any pizza survey be legit when they don’t even visit Santucci’ and Slice who have chosen the top pizza in Philadelphia by other survey’s