World Meeting of Families Official Hymn Not a People Pleaser
The news that there’s an Official Hymn of this fall’s World Meeting of Families got us all excited — until we listened to it online, that is. Talk about your sleeper hits. “Sound the Bell of Holy Freedom” has lyrics by South Philly native Andrew Ciferni, a member of the Norbertine community at Daylesford Abbey in Paoli, set to music by Normand Gouin, the former music director at Old St. Joseph’s National Shrine in Society Hill — the oldest Roman Catholic church in the country. Commenters online haven’t exactly been kind.
There are the full-scale critics:
Seems a pity the words are lost in a melody that drags, very repetitive, makes you think of a funeral, and is very dated.
[T]his Hymm is not what I associate with a Papal event.
There are those who beseech Gouin to pick up the beat:
The melody is lethargic.
I would take it up tempo just a hair.
I would speed it up a little …
There are those who hate the lyrics:
The text … doesn’t have depth for me.
There are those who hate the music:
[G]reat texts … forgettable melody
I thought the theme was that the family was fully alive, the music leaves you fully dead!
There are the “What about the children” naysayers:
I don’t think this hymn will resonate with young people.
[T]he melody is out of touch with families — children cannot sing this and it is not something people will remember. It also drags.
And there’s the Kumbaya crowd:
I would like to hear it without the organ, maybe piano and guitar?
There are a few fans; Jennifer Trofe-Clark, for instance, calls “Sound the Bell of Holy Freedom” “absolutely beautiful.” And then there’s that one guy — Grandpa? Is that you?
I could not hear the song — just nothing.
Follow @SandyHingston on Twitter.