Morning Headlines: Museum of the American Revolution Breaks Ground

It’s expected to open sometime in late 2016, but construction of the Museum of the American Revolution will soon be underway. In fact, the Inquirer’s Stephan Salisbury reports that a symbolic groundbreaking took place yesterday for the $119 million building designed Robert A.M. Stern.

You may recall the museum was previously under a lot of scrutiny when renderings first came out, leaving a number of people unimpressed. “Could [it] be constructed in a way to make its Georgian details feel plausibly like real architecture?” asked Inga Saffron in 2012. Even after its redesign, the building’s appearance was still deemed uninspired.

Read more »

Straight Talk With Bicentennial Architect Peter Chermayeff

Demolition work was underway on the old Visitor Center as of April 26. Photo by the author.

Demolition work was under way on the old Visitor Center as of April 26. Photo: Izzy Kornblatt

The old Independence Visitor Center, constructed by the National Park Service for the 1976 Bicentennial celebration, has not been receiving a lot of love in recent years. A replacement on Independence Mall opened in 2001, rendered the old building basically obsolete; and about a decade ago, the Bicentennial bell housed in the center’s bell tower broke and was never repaired. Now the building is being demolished to make room for the planned Museum of the American Revolution, and no one, as far as I can tell, seems to really mind.

The building’s architect, Peter Chermayeff, doesn’t either. “I’m not surprised that the building is being replaced, because I don’t think of it as very strong or a very important piece of contemporary architecture,” he said when informed of the demolition. “I’m not terribly sorry to hear that it’s going.”

Read more »

Popkin on New MAR Design: Still Mired in Conservatism

museum entrance

“This, I think is most telling about how little this design has moved from mimicry, from its deep, deep conservatism,” says Popkin about the way the museum will meet the street. Rendering via Museum of the American Revolution website.

We asked architecture critic Nathaniel Popkin to comment on the redesign of the American Museum of the Revolution that was approved yesterday by the Philadelphia Art Commission. Popkin has been the most outspoken critic of Robert A.M. Stern’s design for the museum, though he has certainly not been alone (“it’s controversial for its shittiness,” he notes).

After a look at the new renderings, which you can see in a slideshow below, Popkin had to wonder just how much time Stern & co. spent “back at the drawing board” after the Commission requested a redesign. Here’s his assessment:

Read more »

Inquirer Marvels Over the MAR’s New Design

redesign of the museum of the american revolution

The new design of the Museum of the American Revolution. Looks a whole lot like the old design.

Robert A.M. Stern turned in what many considered a subpar design for the Museum of the American Revolution. The building’s cupola, especially, was a subject of consternation; called “ham-fisted” and “Disneyesque” by critics, it was just one of several mawkish, neo-historical design notes that the Philadelphia Art Commission nixed when they told Stern to try again.

And so he did, and today the Inquirer has a piece that trumpets! the! success! of the new Commission-approved design (despite the fact that, in my opinion, it’s pretty much as crappy as the old one). The article, rather than reading like journalism, reads like a press release penned by the museum itself. I don’t know why that is, but I’m aware of the fact, shall we say, that the primary backer of the museum, Gerry Lenfest, is part-owner of the Inquirer; and Lew Katz, another part-owner of the Inquirer, is also a museum board member. (Both facts are disclosed in the Inquirer’s article). These facts could be coincidental, of course. Could be.

Read more »

Morning Headlines: Art Commission Approves Stern Redesign of Museum of American Revolution

Former rendering of the future museum.

Former rendering of the future museum.

It’s not set in stone, but the redesign of the Museum of the American Revolution has received approval from Philadelphia’s Art Commission, which sent Robert A.M. Stern architects back to the drawing board last February. Can you spot the differences between the old design (above) and the new one below?:

Read more »

A Declaration of Independence From Robert Stern Architecture

robert am stern rendering museum of the american revolution

Hidden City co-editor Nathaniel Popkin, who recently published an Inquirer piece about Robert A.M. Stern’s unappealing design for the Museum of the American Revolution (rendering above), has gone a step further in his opposition: He’s written a Declaration of Architectural Independence that serves as the basis for a petition on Change.org.

Those who sign the petition, which is directed to the City of Philadelphia Art Commission, “demand that the Commission use its full Power and Prestige to rectify this abominable design and replace it with one that will, in body and in spirit, embrace the City and the Revolution it purports to celebrate.”

The Declaration in full, below.

Read more »

The Museum of the American Revolution May Need Another Once-Over

robert am stern rendering museum of the american revolution

Designing Philadelphia’s newest museum has proven to be quite a process. Last month, for example, architect Robert A.M. Stern presented renderings of the Museum of the American Revolution to members of Philadelphia’s Art Commission. The commission–whose approval the architect must have before continuing the project–was not fond of said plans.

The building was cited as being bland, but since refashioning its architecture to be more consistent with nearby landmarks (Independence Hall and others of the like), Stern’s adherence to neighborhood character (which isn’t all it’s cracked up to be) comes off as a “willful blindness,” as Hidden City editor and novelist Nathaniel Popkin writes:

Read more »

Morning Headlines: “Milestone Moment” At American Revolution Museum “Any Day”!

american revolution center

Image of the museum’s interior plan via AmericanRevolutionCenter.org

Here’s one way to keep the public excited. CBS Philly reports on “the march toward creation of the Museum of the American Revolution in Philadelphia” (emphases ours):

Although the opening of the museum at 3rd and Chestnut Streets is still a few years off, it’s likely that this week a request for proposals will go out to four companies for package bid to demolish the current building and build the new one.

Museum spokeswoman ZeeAnn Mason expects the hammer to fall perhaps early next year. Then, “The demolition process takes two to three months, then we have an archeological process that — it’s hard to predict exactly how much time that will take — but we’ve allowed at least three to four months in the schedule. The construction’s about two years from that and exhibits need to get installed, so we’re looking at the end of 2016 or early 2017 for opening day.”

For all those who are excited for Robert A.M. Stern’s building to transform into a tourist destination: stand by! “A milestone moment is expected any day“!

Now, on to more urgent news…

Read more »