Why We’re Pissed Stores are Opening on Thanksgiving

We already have Small Business Saturday and Cyber Monday. Do we really need Brown (Gray?) Thursday?

Thanksgiving-OpenI’ve never been a huge camp-outside-Target-in-a-Snuggie-with-a-thermos-of-coffee person. The hot-ticket items every year (Furbies and Wiis come to mind) never left me lusting, and they most definitely did not warrant a 3am wake-up call post-tryptophan-coma.

Um, apparently I’m in the minority.




In 2012, the National Retail Federation reported that 247 million shoppers visited retailers or shopped online during the unofficial long holiday weekend. Aside from that figure being absolutely mind-boggling, it's also telling of an industry looking to further capitalize on a made-up holiday (yeah, I said it) that already raked in $59.1 billion last year alone.

That's why I was thoroughly pissed to see even more stores opening on Thanksgiving this year. Stores including Walmart, Target, Best Buy, Sears, Kmart, Macy's, Kohl's, J.C. Penny, and The Gap will all be open next Thursday—some even as early as 6am. Unfortunately, this isn't much different from last year; many of these stores opened then, too. This year, it's more stores opening at ever earlier. It begs the question: How many years will it take for Thanksgiving to become just another ordinary day?

Evidently, my anger isn't totally unique. Last week, I received a petition from Change.org rallying to make Target close its doors on Thanksgiving. With 91,348 signatures as of publishing, it looks like it's gaining traction. Signer Carol Adele-Jewett commented: "Emergency personnel must work, but shopping is NOT an emergency." And we agree with her; EMS (obviously?) trumps the dash for a new TV.

Black Friday serves its purpose well: killer sales and a hilarious bonding activity after Thanksgiving's gorge-a-thon. Why must we ruin two mutually exclusive holidays by blurring the line between family time and shopping time? We've already expanded to Small Business Saturday and Cyber Monday, meaning there are more than enough opportunities to score a great deal.

What this really means: If someone is out shopping, another someone is working on his or her behalf—on Thanksgiving, when they should be—or could be—with their families. Some would argue that we at Shoppist are the biggest of shopping aficionadas, but even we can put down our credit cards and admit that this is ludicrous. Therefore, we suggest the the only shopping to be done on Thanksgiving is trips to the grocery store for forgotten cranberries and Pillsbury crescents. Because that 157-inch 4D television for $13.99 can wait. Really.

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • Chris Bowen

    So what exactly is your problem with it, I cannot really see the point the article is making. Lets start with some fact, business have been open on Thanksgiving and other holidays for as long as we have been alive. If someone chose to shop or work on a holiday it is their business not ours. If you are forced to work on a holiday it is your right to quit that job. This seems to be another manufactured outrage. And I just LOVE the final sentence.. It is not ok for people to work to sell you a TV but is REQUIRED that people work to see you some cranberry and stuffing.

  • Anonymous

    Chris seriously? Fuck you… We sacrifice thanksgiving and all the joy goes down the drain to keep your fat ass happy to buy shit and this is how you feel? You’re a pathetic sack of shit. You’re welcome we work on thanksgiving asshole