Alleged Rittenhouse Rapist Moves to Center of Immigration Debate

Milton Mateo Garcia is becoming a conservative cause célébre.

The man accused of raping a 26-year-old Philadelphia woman at her Spruce Street home last month is becoming a conservative cause célébre. Because Mayor Nutter this year ended the city’s cooperation with federal immigration authorities, they say, Milton Mateo Garcia could endup going free and unpunished.

Here’s the case from Ryan Lovelace at the conservative National Review:

But if Garcia is acquitted of wrongdoing by the police, he need not worry about potential deportation proceedings. The Philadelphia Police Department will refuse to honor ICE’s detainer at the direction of the mayor. Philly’s executive order No. 1-14, which was signed by Nutter this April, states, “No person in the City who otherwise would be released from custody shall be detained pursuant to an ICE civil immigration detainer request#…#nor shall notice of his or her pending release be provided, unless such person is being released after conviction for a first or second degree felony involving violence and the detainer is supported by judicial warrant.”

If Garcia were released, he would enjoy several city services. In November 2009, Nutter signed executive order 8-09, which provides illegal immigrants with access to Philadelphia’s medical services, mental health services, children’s protective services, city facilities, and other services. The order also forces city employees to refrain from inquiring about a person’s immigration status when determining the person’s benefit eligibility. Healy says he did not know why Garcia chose to come to Philadelphia, a sanctuary city, after being deported last summer. Before his arrest, Garcia worked in the kitchens of three area restaurants for several months,according to Philly.com.

For proponents of Nutter’s action to end cooperation with ICE, though, all of this is a feature, not a bug. Back in February, before Nutter signed the order, I interviewed Nicole Kligerman of the New Sanctuary Movement and discussed this exact issue ahead of time:

Since the folks who have the holds on them have been arrested, should Philadelphians then be concerned that maybe we’re harboring criminals that are missed when we don’t have to?

Deportation is a civil action, it’s not one of the criminal justice system. When police and ICE are working together it’s actually obstructing the criminal justice’s due process to convict and detain people with criminal convictions. If someone commits a crime, they go to jail, they serve their time, they’re rehabilitated and should be released and not undergo this double punishment of being further deported. Ending ICE hold policy will in no way change the criminal justice system as it is — however flawed — as it’s currently working to give out criminal sentences.

All of this hinges, incidentally, on the idea that Garcia will be found innocent of the charges against him. That’s possible, but it probably bears waiting to see if the city’s new immigration policy actually releases rapists onto our city streets.




Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • Charliefoxtrot

    Madness. It’s the only way to describe the amnesty/sanctuary city movement. Professional Latino advocacy groups combined with Chamber of Commerce big biz types who want cheaper (or harder working) labor force are conspiring against the average taxpayer.

    Imagine immigrating legally, saving up the required funds, taking your citizenship tests, medical tests, etc and watching those who don’t get the same treatment.

    Then imagine you’re poor and in Guatemala , and hear that if you make it to a big city in America you’ll be given welfare benefits and health care, and purposely not asked your legal status. Kinda rational to make the trip!

    The signal it sends-that millions openly break the law-undermines our faith in the legal system in a way that is not at all covert. Healthy societies function when citizens understand the rule of law, and self police their own behavior.

  • Rose B.

    When a migrant like Milton Meteo Garcia is arrested, we cannot know his criminal history. He might have a long criminal record going back 10 years or more in his home country. We must not risk making the wrong and dangerous assumption that his slate is clean and decide to treat him like any other “first offender” — he most likely is not. Yet the Sanctuary Movement would have us set aside all prudent caution and treat arrestees who are here illegally like any other citizen who has a clean criminal record. That is a reckless and irresponsible agenda.

  • MydikisLarge

    Mateo is a rapist,and all rapists have raped multiple times,and will most likely rape again.This scum should be deported immediately with extreme prejudice.He will only be burning taxpayer dollars,and adding to our stressed Corrections Dept. anyway

    • Rose B.

      If he’s deported, he’ll come right back. He already did that once.