SCOTUS Rules Against Aereo Streaming TV, Handing Comcast a Win

Philly-based company among the opponents to the new service.

“In a decision with implications for the television industry, the Supreme Court ruled on Wednesday that Aereo, a start-up streaming service, violated copyright laws by capturing broadcast signals on miniature antennas and delivering them to subscribers for a fee,” the New York Times reports. “The 6-3 decision was a victory for the major television networks, which had argued that Aereo’s business model amounted to a theft of their programming.”

The ruling was also a victory for Comcast, the Philly-based cable giant, which was concerned that Aereo might upend the business model under which cable companies pay to carry Comcast-owned NBC affiliates on their local systems. Comcast had joined a consortium of other media companies in challenging Aereo’s business model.




The Street explains:

CBS , Disney's ABC, Comcast's NBC and 21st Century Fox had charged that Aereo was reselling its programming for a fee without paying for it. The broadcasters argued that Aereo should be required to pay each television station in each designated market area, known as a DMA. Aereo's business plan is predicated on not having to pay those so-called carriage fees. Throughout its many legal battles, Aereo has countered that it's simply making it easier for consumers to access a service which they already get.

Although Aereo had long promised to offer its service in Philadelphia, that never occurred. It now seems unlikely.

View the full decision here:

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.