Welcome to Pennsylvania. Would You Like Fries With That?

The new unemployment numbers aren’t as great as they seem.

Stop us if you’ve heard this before: Yes, Pennsylvania’s unemployment rate has dropped again. No, it’s not as great as it seems at first blush.

Take a gander:


So yes, the unemployment rate in Pennsylvania declined to 6.2 percent in February. Almost makes the economy seem normal, right? 42,000 more Pennsylvanians are working than a year ago; there are 13,000 fewer looking for work.

On the other hand: 59,000 Pennsylvanians have dropped out of the workforce in the last year. That’s a decline of 0.9 percent. That means two things: More Pennsylvanians are giving up on work in the state than are finding it here. And that 0.9 percent decline is kind of extraordinary — the national workforce decline by just 0.1 percent.

The declining unemployment rate, then, is party a function of despair at finding a job in the state. Not exactly the storyline Gov. Corbett will be trumpeting in his campaign press releases.

But hey, for kicks, let’s look at a second chart. Here’s a summing up of all the available jobs in the state:


Total nonfarm employment in Pennsylvania grew by 24,600 jobs in the last year, a 0.4 percent increase. (Nationally, that number improved by about 1 percent during the sametime period.) But here’s the crazy number: Most of the job growth came from “leisure and hospitality” jobs — the low-paid, often menial work of staffing hotels and serving hamburgers — 19,300 total.

We don’t have ready access to state statistics on this, but nationally, workers in the leisure and hospitality industries make $13.76 an hour, and work 25.7 hours a week: A wage adding up to $18,388 a year. For reference point: The federal poverty line for a family of four is 23,850.

One more important note: The Pennsylvania job sector that had the biggest losses in the last year was manufacturing, with 7,000 jobs lost. Using national statistics again, the average worker in that sector make $24.72 an hour and worked 40.7 hours a week, for a wage totaling roughly $52,317 a year.

If the federal workforce statistics on salaries bear any resemblance to real life, Pennsylvania biggest-losing sector shed $366 million in wages over the last year — while the fastest-growing sector added just $354 million.

Gov. Corbett is trumpeting his leadership along with the news of Pennsylvania’s declining unemployment numbers. But a peek under the hood shows an economy shedding middle-class jobs, and replacing them with those that let you work and still be poor. It doesn’t sound like good news.

Around the Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.