Court Overturns Pennsylvania Voter ID Law

Was seen as effort to block Democratic voters from getting to the polls.


Breaking: Pennsylvania’s controversial voter ID law has been overturned:





Not everybody was happy:


Philly Mag reported last July:

As the state Supreme Court mulls the constitutionality of Pennsylvania’s voter ID law, a new study adds some context to the debate. The study, commissioned by the AFL-CIO, found that between 35,239 and 36,613 did not come out to vote last year because of confusion arising from the passage of the law, which was not actually in effect. The union conducted the study by measuring the turnout among those registered voters with ID and those without ID, figuring that those who didn’t thought their ballots wouldn’t be counted. They found that those without ID were half as likely to vote as those with ID. And those people, by a 2.5-to-1 margin, tended to be Democrats.

The biggest loser, if the law had been upheld, was Philadelphia.

Let’s clarify: If you’re poor in Philadelphia, there’s a good chance you’ve never needed a driver’s license. (Cars are expensive to maintain and park; and there’s a functioning public transit system here.) There’s a good chance you’ve never been to college. There’s a good chance, generally, that you’ve never needed to obtain any of the types of identification needed to vote.

Which means, ultimately, that the law could not have been more perfectly crafted to keep Philadelphia—and its huge population of impoverished city-dwellers—from making a difference in the state’s elections.

Around The Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • tonyb

    OMG. I feel embarrassed to live in this state. Why do we have a photo on a driver’s license? How does one purchase a car, a house, get a checking account, or credit card without an ID? Can one obtain public assistance without identification? I guess the next procedure in this state will be the PA criminal system will be eliminating mug shots when a person is arrested. This state should be ashamed. What a disgusting way to get votes.

    • Jane Yavis

      Tony, As your post indicates, you aren’t really interested in why it was stricken, and you already know Public Assistance, Public Housing and those working for State or Local Government have ID. – The State says only a Photo ID issued by Motor Vehicle is acceptable. I would spend time trying to explain why that’s a burden, but your closing sentance tells me you are still crying foul over an imaginary voter intimidation that never happened.

  • JohnRz

    Corbett just got one step closer to the door!

  • tonyb

    Oh Jane…God forbid you need to go the DMV for an ID. Maybe if they offer a monetary incentive the line to obtain an ID would run for miles. I do think Harrisburg should create a more efficient way of obtaining an ID. Jane, have you ever been to Europe? Everyone has a national ID. And no Jane I am not crying foul over voter intimidation. You sound like someone that lives with cats.