Occupy Philadelphia Is Suing the City

Claims its freedom of speech was violated.

26 protestors affiliated with Occupy Wall Street have sued the city, claiming that when they were kicked off Dilworth Plaza in 2011, their freedom of speech and freedom of assembly were violated.

Specifically, the protestors are suing Police Commissioner Charles Ramsey and a host of other PPD officers. In an earlier lawsuit Occupy protesters were acquitted of various charges, including failure to disperse and obstructing a highway. The results of that suit, the group claims, proves that they had every right to Occupy Dilworth Plaza, and that the Philadelphia police had no right to kick them off.

An aside: The lawsuit, though it appears to have merit, seems to reflect a broader sub-strategy of the Occupy movement. Though it focused primarily on economic injustice, much of the on-the-ground conflict pitted protesters against police officers, in this city and elsewhere. While no one was exactly happy about getting booted off Dilworth Plaza or Zuccotti Park, many of the Occupiers seemed to revel in the confrontation, which fed into their narrative about corrupt, entrenched power. It also gave them a tangible enemy against whom to rebel — something that’s much harder to do when talking about income inequality. Occupy Philly’s lawsuit may seem like a coda to the events of two years ago, but it’s actually very much in keeping with the spirit of the movement.


Around The Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • jkudler

    Simon, you don’t have this quite right. Folks aren’t suing over being
    kicked off; they are suing for being arrested for no reason (also, they
    weren’t acquitted of criminal charges in a “lawsuit” – it was a criminal
    trial). A much larger group of people was kicked off of Dilworth, but
    the police arbitrarily arrested these 26 people only. I was there, and
    literally one group of kettled/blockaded protesters was arrested, and
    the rest of the people weren’t.