Keep Out the Dunes, Margate

Before voting on an expensive replenishment project, residents should realize how little the dunes helped Ventnor and A.C. during Sandy.

Thereʼs a storm a-brewinʼ in Margate , and itʼs all about, well, storms. More specifically, itʼs about the construction of sand dunes — a project rejected by the communities of Longport and Margate when the Army Corps of Engineers first proposed it in 2003. Dunes were, however, erected in Ventnor and Atlantic City, so, luckily for Margate residents, they can look to the performance of those dunes as they face this latest go-round.

Itʼs no wonder that Hurricane Sandy has brought this project to the fore. Lots of folks suffered damage to their homes, and the municipalities of Absecon Island also incurred great expense to rebuild and repair — all in time for the summer season. So itʼs only natural, I suppose, to think that the dunes may have mitigated that damage and that maybe theyʼre a good idea after all. Margate has decided to include a nonbinding referendum on its ballot in November asking residents if they want the dunes now after all. Because of the serious tax implications, however, before Margatians pull the lever, it behooves them to be educated on the subject.

The Absecon Island Coastal Storm Risk Management project was initially conceived, researched, and constructed as a mechanism to “reduce storm damage due to flooding and wave attack and minimize shoreline erosion.” It is a project designed to maximize beach replenishment. The construction of a berm and large dunes should, in theory, contain coastal high tides and waves lower than dune height and keep the sand on the beach. Ventnor residents would argue that they donʼt do that and that, in fact, the sand washes out to sea and the city is left with the expense of creating new beaches after a decent storm. But Sandy wasnʼt a decent storm, it was a whopper. How would the dunes, as planned, have fared in a storm that size? I asked a Margate official familiar with the project from its inception, and this is what I learned.

The perfect storm last October caused damage due to high winds, flooding and sand deposited inland. There were 65 homes in Margate that sustained significant damage, only nine of which were beach-block. The homes most affected were in the 200 and 300 blocks of Margate, not beachfront. The bay rose up and flooded the island. The waves crashed onto the dunes, where they exist, and deposited tons of sand inland. The sand crashed onto the communities of Ventnor and Atlantic City like liquid cement, carried by waters that receded, leaving sand and debris everywhere. In addition, in Ventnor, after the waters receded, the ponding that occurred between the bulkhead and the dune did not perk, as Army Corp engineers predicted it would, leaving a stagnant pool of algae-covered water as an attraction to insects and adventuresome children.

So while the jury is out on how effective the dunes are at beach retention, itʼs pretty clear that they have no affect on mitigating storm damage from a superstorm and, in fact, add the additional risk of damage caused by the immense amount of sand that moves inland — not to mention the additional cost of removing that sand and replacing it on the beach. And what will it cost Margate to move sand around after a storm? Nine percent of the cost to rebuild the huge dunes when they are washed inland will be borne by Margate residents. That figure is guesstimated by the ACE to be more $418 million over 50 years for all four municipalities. Thatʼs dune maintenance. The cost of shoveling the sand to the beach and the cost of purchasing easements will be completely borne by residents. And beachfront homeowners donʼt sell that million-dollar view for peanuts.

An easement in Harvey Cedars was acquired at a cost of $375,000; Margate will need to procure 10 such easements. If the beach replenishment project moves forward, surely beach-block homeowners will petition reassessment of their homes, and surely those assessments will be reduced, meaning a sizable reduction in tax revenue. So, less money coming in and a contractual obligation to have skin in the game financially. How to fund that shortfall? Taxes will go up for all residents.

The dunes will cost a bundle of money, and they donʼt mitigate flooding or wind damage, the greatest components of damage during Sandy. By some accounts, they cause more damage than protection, and still the feds would like Margate to sign on. I smell something more than salt air.

Around The Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • glennk

    In Margate a big reason we had sand in the beach block street ends by the beach was because somebody in the City Gov’t made the stupid mistake of piling sand up in front of the bulk heads the day before the storm hit allowing the storm to basically use that sand as a ramp to leap over and carry with it part of the beach. Even at that very few homes along the beach front suffered significant damage. Most of the damage being caused by the one really high tide during Sandy. I was present through the entire storm in Margate as my home is 5 blocks from the beach on an old sand dune area 15 ft. above sea level. I had 2.5 ft. of sea water from the BAY in my street, the most I’d ever seen in 35 yrs. When the eye of the storm came over us I went down to Atlantic ave. and the entire length of it was bone dry from one end of Margate to the other. The next morning I drove all the way to the end of the Island on Pacific ave, to the AC Inlet. Again, most of the flooding was on the bayside of the Island in Ventnor and AC as well. Longport which is one block wide got it from both the Bay and the Ocean, as would be expected. The same thing happened in 1962 in the great ASh Wed. Nor’easter in Longport, only then it was far worse because we had 5 major high tides. It’s a myth spread by the NJ State Gov’t and NJDEP that only places with dunes did well in the storm. Margate without significant dunes , did no better or worse then it’s neighboring towns of Ventnor and AC , both of which have full Army Beach systems.