Geno Auriemma Is Right About Notre Dame

It’s time for them to play fair with the Big East

From afar, Geno Auriemma is not easy to like. The UConn women’s basketball coach can be brusque and arrogant. He isn’t always so friendly to the press. And it doesn’t help that his teams win a lot, so we see plenty of Auriemma, perhaps too much.

This week, at Big East media day Auriemma, who spent most of his formative years in Norristown, said something that really angered folks. This time, though, instead of being controversial and overbearing, he was absolutely right.

The target of Auriemma’s remarks was Notre Dame, which has lived a dual life for the past 16 years, housing its so-called “Olympic sports” in the Big East Conference, while continuing to enjoy the benefits of football independence. Auriemma said that the Big East’s current membership problems could have been cured had the Irish become a full-fledged part of the conference, rather than engaging in a marriage of convenience–for ND.

“If Notre Dame had come in as a football and basketball school when they came in, we wouldn’t have a problem,” Auriemma said. “Miami wouldn’t have left. Virginia Tech wouldn’t have left. Boston College wouldn’t have left. We probably wouldn’t have any of these issues, would we?”

He’s damn right about that, and it is mystifying the Big East allowed the Irish to find safe harbor for its other sports, while its football team has been allowed to do its own thing. It’s like a marriage in which one spouse is allowed to have a little something on the side. Notre Dame brings little to the Big East in men’s basketball, and frankly, few care about the other sports. Only football matters when it comes to ND, and the Big East has allowed the Irish to keep its valuable gridiron franchise separate. Worse, whenever Notre Dame has flirted with conference affiliation, it has looked to the Big Ten. It’s a wonder no one from the Big East has filed a police report, because the Irish are abusing the hell out of the league.

If the Big East had any guts, it would have issued an ultimatum to Notre Dame years ago: Join for football, or you’re out for everything else. Even if that pushed the school to the Big Ten, at least the Big East would have maintained some of its dignity. As it stands now, the conference looks silly allowing the arrangement and harboring (microscopic) hopes the Irish will join it for football.

As the conference realignment carousel spins wildly out of control, each new week bringing more news of uncertainty and rumors of oddball affiliations. There is no league more vulnerable than the Big East, which could well disintegrate in the next few months. If Missouri leaves the Big 12, it’s entirely likely the conference could target Big East members Louisville, Cincinnati and West Virginia as new members to get the gang up to 12 and assure the conference of a lucrative football playoff. Should those three bolt, Connecticut and Rutgers will do everything possible to get out, even if the conference raises the exit fee to $100 million.

The Big East is trying to “strengthen” itself with the likes of Houston, SMU, Boise State, Navy, Air Force and the College of Cardinals, none of which can be found in a conference that has a BCS automatic bid. Should the league recruit those strays into the fold, it should change its name to the Ellis Island Conference. “Give me your tired, your poor … ”

And this is what Temple and Villanova are fighting to join? Do they really want to join forces with schools like Houston and Memphis, who don’t exactly have long, storied histories of playing by the rules, particularly on the basketball court? Is it worth splintering the Big Five in order to get membership in a conference that will have no chance of matching the SEC, Big Ten and the other big boys in terms of heft and national prominence? Fighting to join a dying conglomeration makes no sense, especially since the Big East’s personality could change completely within a year.

Furthermore, deciding to invest $30 million or so in its football program, in order to join a league that has a shaky future, is hardly a good idea for Villanova. It would be better to focus on building the best basketball program it can and pumping some of that money into Jay Wright’s salary, the better to keep him on board if the school must join Georgetown, St. John’s, Marquette and the other Big East schools that don’t play I-A football in a new conference.

As for Temple, the Owls might be better suited staying put in the MAC for football and playing in the Atlantic 10 for everything else, even if Xavier and Dayton bolt the conference for the new Catholic Confederation. Hanging with C-USA rejects, Mountain West expats and stray WAC members is not a recipe for national prominence or institutional sanity. Temple would be far better served by taking a leadership role in helping the A-10 get stronger through reasonable expansion – if the aforementioned schools depart.

More importantly, Temple and Villanova must recognize what their true essences are. They are not huge powerhouses with gigantic fan bases capable of filling large football stadiums each week. As the college athletics landscape morphs into a collection of money-grabbing programs trying to feed the bottom line, neither school fits the profile, and it’s silly for them to think they do. Better to maximize what they have than try–and fail–to be something else. Yes, that strategy could be dangerous, particularly if the 64 or so biggest programs break away and govern themselves. But let’s be honest about this; Villanova and Temple don’t belong with Oklahoma, Alabama and Ohio State. And they don’t belong in Big East Lite.

Given the way Notre Dame has been playing football lately, maybe that’s a good spot for the Irish.



  • What is it with Temple and prosperity? The Owls looked great posting two straight shutout wins and then stumble at Bowling Green Saturday. Temple still leads the MAC East Division, but the margin for error has been officially eliminated. Focus, people, focus.
  • Hats off to Delaware Valley College, which improved to 8-0 with a rout of King’s College. The Aggies get a week off before finishing the season with tough games against Lycoming and Widener.
  • Last week’s going-to-the-mattresses negotiating stances by the NBA and its players will lead to more cancelled games. If the league keeps it up, it won’t be hard at all for fans to find other outlets for their interest, and more importantly, their money. If the NFL could figure out a way to save its season, the NBA should follow suit. First step: disingenuous owners move off their 50-50 split stance. Results will follow.


Around The Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • jerry shotframe

    Who cares about the conference musical chair stuff. In Philly sports it is time for the U!

  • Steve Russ

    Why blame Notre Dame? It’s the Big East who has the policy of letting schools in on a “partial” basis. And, do you really think that the only school in the Country that has an exclusive contract with a major network – would join the Big East in football if they were threatened? You don’t need to spend money on a trip to fantasy Land. Apparently, you are already there.

    ND just opened a multi MULTI million dollar complex that will house all of their 20 something sports including a new hockey complex. They have also signed a contract with NBC to televise some of their hockey games.

    Gino was right when he said that ND football would have solved some of the Big East’s problems but anyone who thinks they have any leverage in forcing ND to join is 6 points short of a touchdown.

  • Knute Rockne

    As they say in Ireland Mr. Bradley, “Pogue mo thoin.” Go Irish!

  • TUtuff

    The stuff about TU and Nova being forever relegated to I-AA or mid-major status in football is some of the most foolish stuff Ive ever heard.
    You act like football program power is static, that the teams that are good now will always be good, its impossible to grow a program or for a bad team to become great.
    How long ago was UCONN I-AA? Houston has been a top 20 program each of the last few years. ECU has won something like 3 of 4 confrence titiles and average 50k+ plus a game. Temple went 1-22 during 05 and 06. SInce then, TU is 2-1 (if replay doesnt screw TU at Storrs) against the big east, including clobering their champ last year, 1-0 against the ACC, been to their first bowl game since 79 where they beat UCLA for 3 1/2 quarters (when peirce went down), and beat PSU @PSU for 55 mins last year and 57 mins this year, has gone 20-8 over their last 28 games, and even if they lose out will have their most win in a 3 year span in TU history, and has seen average attendance go from 15,582 in 2008 to 34,372 so far this year.
    How good was UCLA, Miami, FSU, PSU, ND 15-20 years ago? What about Boise State and Utah and TCU and UCONN?

  • Brian Ewart

    That’s nonsense about Villanova making a $30million investment in football. That money isn’t coming from the endowment or from a general fund, it is money specifically allocated by donors for an upgrade in football. If they don’t upgrade, that money won’t be available to pay Jay Wright more.

    If there is a legitimate concern about losing Wright, then Villanova better make sure they try hard to give him what he wants: an FBS football team. Wright has been one of the biggest proponents of Villanova’s football upgrade plan both behind the scenes, and now publicly.

    The real financial concern for Villanova isn’t the short-term up front costs – they know where they can get that money and are able to raise it – it is the long-term financial outlook. With the old Big East football line-up, Villanova had a good idea what the revenue numbers would look like and they seemed favorable toward the university’s ability to fund an FBS program long term. However, until the new Big East membership is settled, it will be difficult to predict future revenue.

  • Pat H

    What a horribly ill-informed, stupid article. (a) Notre Dame has always played fail with the Big East. They have stated from day one that they wanted to remain independent in football. If the Big East accepted that arrangement, don’t fault Notre Dame. (b) Notre Dame has NEVER flirted with the Big Ten or any other conference. Do some actual research (you know, journalism), before writing something so blatantly, factually wrong. (c) Notre Dame offers nothing in men’s basketball? Notre Dame has consistently been in the top 5 or 6 in the conference in the last several years, earning several Player and Coach of the Year awards. Wasn’t it just last year that Notre Dame was a #2 seed in the NCAA Tournament? Again, morte horrible “journalism.” and (d) Finally, the worst piece of “journalism” – “few care about the other sports.” You may not care, but many people in those sports (including the Big East conference commissioner and members) care that Notre Dame women won the NCAA soccer championship last year and lost in the bastketball championship game (after beating Mr. Auriemma and Pat Summitt in the NCAA Tournament – the first time that had EVER been accomplished). As another commenter pointed out, Notre Dame hockey has a brand new facility, will have several games on Versus and lost in the National Championship just 2 or 3 years ago.

    I have found many of your columns to be off-base. This one is just so factually incorrect in a transparent attempt to vent and rail against Notre Dame that it is shameful. No wonder newspapers have gone out of business if this is considered journalism. The good news is, your shoddy work has just lost a weekly reader.

  • joe

    Have any of you been to a Villanova football game? Their side might be close to being full . But the other side, thats another story.So for Villanova to move up to Div. 1 in football doesn’t make sense. I feel if they moved to PPL park in Chester, even less people would show up.

    As far as the NBA, cancel the whole season!!

  • Ed

    Geno’s a loudmouth and one of the most overrated coaches in sports.