Taking the Shame Burger Challenge

Four guys, tons of meat and scrapple … yum!

Let this be a lesson: Read emails carefully. A few weeks ago, Philadelphia Inquirer sports columnist John Gonzalez sent out an invitation: “The Wishing Well in Bella Vista has something called The Shame Burger Challenge: It’s two double Shame Burgers (topped with scrapple, egg and cheese), two orders of fries and two beers. You have to do it in 45 minutes. Who’s interested?”

Forty-five minutes? I thought I’d finish in a half hour, tops. What I overlooked was one critical word: “double.”

When the day of our meat reckoning arrived, John had managed to convince two other friends/suckers to join him. We knew we were in over our heads when the first plate appeared. I’d eaten a Shame Burger before and it went down easy. But these patties were thicker; the scrapple, more formidable. Each burger was packed with four slabs of meat and towered nearly a foot high. There’s a reason that only a handful of moronic gastronomic superstars have made it to the bar’s Wall of Shame. (They swear that one guy finished in four minutes; I’d like to see where they buried him after his intestines exploded.)

The countdown began and we dug in. My strategy was to maintain a slow, steady pace. The trick, I thought, would be to treat this like any other meal. I usually have a bottomless stomach—just three days earlier, I’d polished off five slices of pizza (including three topped with cheesesteak meat) and two beers in 15 minutes without breaking a sweat. How hard could this stunt be?

In the history of miscalculations, this ranked somewhere between the Battle of Little Bighorn and the 18-inch Stonehenge from This Is Spinal Tap. Five minutes into the gorging, I was already in trouble. The burgers were piled so high, it was impossible to eat them whole. I set aside one patty and one block of Scrapple and started working on the other half. It wasn’t going down easy. Ten minutes passed, and I took a look around the table. Andy was exhaling deeply. Joe looked a few shades paler than when he started. The Wishing Well’s head chef kindly brought us a bucket. “This,” John said, “was the worst idea ever.”

By the 30-minute mark, we’d slowed to a crawl. Each french fry felt like chewing gum as I gnawed away, trying to get them down without triggering a gag reflex. I suggested we at least try to finish our beers. With a big lead, I chugged my second Kenzinger and won the drink-off. It was the most shallow of victories.

As the final seconds ticked away, we declared a three-way tie for last place, and awarded best in show to Joe, who sprinted out to an early lead but was felled by a nasty case of the meat sweats. Afterward, there was no post-game chatter, no talk of our failure over a few pints. All we wanted was to sleep and perhaps induce vomiting. As I stumbled home with egg remnants on my fingers like evidence from a crime scene I just escaped, I wasn’t bloated. This wasn’t like Thanksgiving dinner, where you pop a button on your pants and doze off on the couch. I just felt nauseous. If I smelled so much as a whiff of a Big Mac, it would have looked like an outtake from The Exorcist. We called it PTMD: post-traumatic meat disorder.

If you’d enjoy seeing four idiots fail miserably as John’s lovely, but cruel, fiancée Colleen Wolfe takes pleasure in our pain, then watch. [Link to story on Philly.com] And if you think we’re wimps, I encourage you to take the Shame Challenge yourself. Your GI tract and your dignity will never be the same.

Around the Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.