Rum Cocktail Recipes: Rumor Wins At Rittenhouse Spring Fest Preview


Last Thursday was the fancy-pantsy Rittenhouse Row Spring Festival Preview Party, held in the Grand Ballroom at the Ritz-Carlton. There was plenty of food, booze and amusements for the well-heeled swells who attended, but at the center of it all was the official Foobooz-sanctioned Captain Morgan Black cocktail competition–which we sanctioned mostly because it was a good excuse for everyone to drink a little rum get all pirate-y for a night.

The challenge was thus: To create an original cocktail using Captain Morgan spiced rum as a primary ingredient. And bartenders from all over the city rose to the task. After the jump, check out a few of the rum cocktail recipes–including the one for the winning drink: The Captain Rumorita, courtesy of bartender Scott Innes of Rumor.

But first, here are a few of the other uses for your pirate juice.


Drink name: Alfa Punch Buggy Black

Bartender name: George Donahue


·     Captain Morgan Black Spiced Rum

·     Muddled Tangelo segments and 2 pieces of Pineapple

·     fresh squeezed lemon

·     dash simple syrup

·     topped off with San Pellegrino Pompello (Grapefruit)

Served in a rocks glass


Drink name: Strawberry Swizzle

Bartender name: Samantha Marzullo


·     Captain Morgan Black Spiced Rum

·     Fresh muddled strawberries

·     Lime juice

·     Simple syrup

·     Ginger ale

·     Strawberry garnish

Served in a rocks glass with a salted rim


Drink name: Sweet & Spice

Bartender name: Mark Yanga


·     Captain Morgan Black Spiced Rum

·     Lime juice

·     Simple syrup

·     Perfect Puree Sweet Ginger Puree

·     Sixpoint Sweet Action Ale

·     Lime wheel garnish

Served in a Collins glass with a lime wheel garnish


Drink name: Captain’s Castaway

Bartender name: Richard Millichap


.     Captain Morgan Black Spiced Rum

.     Lime juice

.     Sugar syrup

Served in a highball glass


Drink name: Sailor’s Warning

Bartender name: Jon Borror


·     Captain Morgan Black Spiced Rum

·     Grapefruit juice

·     Lime juice

·     Orange juice

·     Honey syrup

·     House made Falernum syrup

·     Absinthe

·     Finish with Lemon Hart 151

Served in a highball glass


And finally, this year’s winning drink:


Drink name: Captain Rumorita

Bartender name: Scott Innes


·     Captain Morgan Black Spiced Rum

·     Cointreau

·     Fresh lime juice

·     Sour mix

·     Splash of cranberry juice

·     Splash of sprite

Served up, in a martini glass

Around the Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.