Revisited And Reviewed: Chip Roman’s Blackfish Is Better than Ever

You’ve heard the story before: Young chef opens shoebox-size BYO. Cooks for a few dozen people every night. The critics fall in love. He keeps it humming for a spell, staying small—until suddenly he can’t resist any longer. Chefs may get all the love, but restaurateurs? They get the money.

So he opens another place. Why not? We’re talking about a guy who used to cook at Le Bec-Fin. People give Place Number Two the benefit of the doubt—at least to begin with. It makes the Philly Mag 50 top five. Squeaks into Esquire, too. Watch out, Jose Garces.

Flash-forward a couple years.

Place Number Two calls it quits. Nobody much laments it. We’ve still got the little BYO we first fell for. Until the shutters close on that, too.

By the time Place Number Three is born (as a clone of Place Two), and Place Four stirs serious befuddlement with crab scrapple, “pig wings,” burgers on doughnut rolls, and cooking blunders all over the place, it’s almost as though good old Place Number One never existed at all.

That’s not Chip Roman’s story—not yet, at least. But it is a cautionary tale. Roman, like Daniel Stern (of Gayle and Rae, now both closed, MidAtlantic which closes tonight and R2L which remains open), made his bones at Le Bec-Fin. He went out on his own with Blackfish, a small BYO that overcame its Conshohocken address to rise to the top of Philly Mag’s Best Restaurants list. And while he kept his restaurateur ambitions in check a bit longer than Stern did, last year he busted out of the BYO box by backing Mica, in Chestnut Hill, and Ela, in Queen Village (about a block from the old Gayle).

Mica didn’t quite do it for me—at least not all the way, as Blackfish had. Ela, my main review in this month’s issue of Philadelphia magazine, captivated me more—but even though Roman’s not in that kitchen, it is another distraction, and I wondered whether his expansion into Philadelphia had impaired his excellence at Blackfish.

There are some questions that only a five-course tasting menu can answer. (Other questions, like the time-honored “How did that no-account bastard get to be a restaurant critic?,” can only be answered with peals of maniacal laughter.) Then there are still more questions—and this turned out to be one of them—that can only be answered by a five-course tasting menu plus a couple extra courses. But that includes an amuse-bouche—a kusshi oyster on the half-shell, sprinkled with salmon-colored trout roe that popped between the teeth as only large caviar can. It left my companion wanting more kick, but to me it was a pure, saline evocation of the ocean, needing no other embellishment beyond the faint smell of the seaweed that cradled the shell.

The next dish blew us both out of the water. Here was embellishment in overdrive: striped bass crudo slicked with a concentrated yuzu syrup—a wallop of citrus both sweet and bracing—that gave way to the pin-and-needle tingle of pink peppercorns, moderated with a subtle, cleanly articulated balm of micro cilantro.

It couldn’t get better than that, only different. Roman has been wrapping cured salmon around fried eggs since Blackfish’s early days, and what this heavy hors d’oeuvre lacked in excitement (on the heels of that crudo, particularly), it made up for in mellow comfort. A runny yolk, a diaphanously thin potato chip, and a fair heap of cool-but-not-chilly salmon: It’s the sort of thing you can picture the last of the Romonovs eating, imprisoned with their cook at the Alexander Palace, before the Bolsheviks put an end to all that.

Next came truffled gnocchi with a mild chicken sauce—honest and bone-warming fare on a very cold evening, but destined to fade in the memory of the duck that followed.

Fanned out over a smear of parsnip puree, the rose-colored petals of meat were a phenomenally juicy reminder of why we eat duck breast to begin with. Not as a vehicle for cherry compote or red wine and plum sauce, or whatever sweet accompaniment often steals the show, but for the gamy succulence the lean meat retains when cooked by careful hands. The side of pureed mustard greens may have been pimped beyond recognition with sugar and sherry vinegar (not necessarily a cause for complaint), but the fowl achieved perfection on its own terms, slowing the pace of our meal to the most enjoyable crawl as each bite became smaller, needing only a swipe in its own luxuriant jus to lull us into a drawn-out rhythm between it and sips of a seriously good pinot noir.

Dessert came too quickly: a raspberry beignet that was fine, but rather slight given what had preceded it. As the pinot opened up further, I would have been game to start over and order another five courses, if only so I could sit a while longer in the spare white dining room. We had a cheese course instead, highlighted by a creamy Morbier whose layer of vegetable ash separated the morning milking from the evening one.

The first time I ate at Blackfish, in 2007, I sat next to the stack of cookbooks from Alice Waters and Charlie Trotter that were the splashiest decorations there. Those authors, it was clear, registered to me as Roman’s heroes. Four and a half years later, they seem more like his colleagues. Expanding into Philadelphia hasn’t impaired Roman at all. Dinner now is better than it was then. The restaurant—staffed by polished but understated servers who know when to appear and when to make themselves scarce, how to pace a meal and how to extend it when the mood is right—breathes with confidence and ease. Our five courses and their bookends spanned a wonderful range of tones, from the austere oyster and subtle fowl to the almost gaudy (but still tightly controlled) flourishes of the yuzu’d and pink-peppered bass crudo.

So long as Roman’s first place stayed this good while Places Two and Three got up and running, I’ll just go ahead and say it now: Come on, Chef. Bring on Place Four.

Blackfish [Official Site]

Photos by Ryan Lavine

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • Dennis

    Um, yeah…I’m going to have to go ahead and disagree with you there. The food, while quite decent, just doesn’t outrank the cramped, loud, and downright uncomfortable atmosphere of the restaurant. The understaffed servers that you mentioned literally trip over you trying to circumnavigate the 12 inches of space they have between tables.
    And I go to an indoor restaurant in the summertime to get out of the heat, not to feel like I’m still outside. That place needs either an AC, or if they have one (which is real hard to tell) a much bigger one.
    There’s a reason Urbanspoon has them listed at a 70%. Just sayin’.

  • HugeBeard

    Who cares about urbanspoon?

  • badjack

    I hear the Olive Garden has super awesome AC in the summer, and plenty of space between tables.

  • Dennis

    Easy, trolls. Urbanspoon, like Yelp, is a viable review site. And Badjack is completely correct about Olive Garden. However, that point does nothing to detract from the fact that we had a lousy experience at Blackfish.

  • Christine difalco

    Blackfish has been on my to-do list since it opened. Finally had the chance to dine there in January and was impressed with the fare offered. The place is small but on a cold winter night , I enjoyed the coziness of the back room. Actually was glad to have a party wall keep the chilly air at bay from the front of the property. The staff do seem to juggle around the tables yet it appears to be a dance they are accustomed to. Food is excellent and not much in the Montgomery county area can compare to the unique offerings on the menu. Mr Roman’s best feature here is byob. Makes an exquisite meal