What They’re Saying: Mayock, Kiper On Smith

NCAA Football: Louisville at South Florida

Here’s a roundup of what Mike Mayock, Mel Kiper Jr., Jon Gruden and others think about the Eagles’ selection of Louisville OLB Marcus Smith. Plus, some Round 2 and 3 projections for the Birds.

Said Mayock: “Pretty exciting edge guy. I love the 3-4 outside linebacker with upside. I question his core strength a little bit on tape. The important thing ultimately is: Can this kid play? And right now, what do they have coming off the edge? They got Connor Barwin on one side and they’ve got 32-year-old Trent Cole on the other side. So in that 3-4 scheme, he’s a perfect fit. You may argue that it was a little early, but they already traded down from 22, they picked up some extra picks. I applaud the pick because it attacks an area of need for them.”




And Kiper: "He’s on the rise because of his athletic prowess and that versatility. And what did the Eagles need? They needed a corner, wide receiver and a pass rusher. And they got the pass rusher in Marcus Smith. A couple other guys were on the board. Demarcus Lawrence, Boise State. Jeremiah Attaochu, Georgia Tech. They had some options for a pass-rusher. They took a guy that you thought maybe would be a second-round pick in the late first round."

And Gruden: "He has sack production at Louisville. But a lot of it, he’s unblocked. He [former Louisville head coach Charlie Strong] put him on the move a lot in their scheme. But he has an excellent motor, a lot of versatility. He can play right end, he can play outside linebacker, you can move him around as a joker in the sub package. Plays hard on a weekly basis, and he’s been well-trained."

Bob McGinn of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel got this breakdown on Smith from scouts:

Was a high school QB in Columbus, Ga., but was shifted to defense almost immediately. Started 31 games at DE, finishing with 86 tackles (32½ for loss), 24 sacks and 11 big plays. "He will be drafted higher than you think because he has some pass-rush potential," one scout said. "Might be a pretty good investment. His best production came when he had his hand in the dirt and rushed. I don't see him as an immediate starter. He doesn't have the lower-body build to anchor the run. It will take a year to teach him to play." Played standing up about 70% of the snaps as a senior. "Kind of a hard fit for a 4-3," said another scout. "He's got a knack for rushing. Some of it's inside. He rushes against backs. He's more athletic than Attaochu."

Doug Farrar of SI.com gives the Eagles a B- for the Smith pick:

Projected by most as a second-round prospect, Smith has the power, speed and turn around the edge to make things happen at the NFL level. And in that regard, he’s not as much of a reach as some may assume.

Greg A. Bedard of The MMQB offers his take:

A bit early for Louisville OLB Marcus Smith, at No. 26, but he’s a good player. Looks like the end is near for Trent Cole. That’s too bad. He’s a terrific football player.

Pete Prisco of CBSSports.com gives the Eagles a B:

The Eagles need a young pass rusher, and he can provide that. He's athletic and fits their scheme. I get it.

Josh Norris of Rotoworld had Smith ranked as his 33rd overall player:

The more I watched the Cardinal, the more I liked him. Not only can he bend around tackles, Smith loves to chase from the backside and converts speed to power with good length and hand use. I know I keep bringing up hands and technical skill, but it really does set great rushers that can win on counter moves apart from good ones that have one trick.

Eric Galko of the Sporting News offers his scouting report on Smith:

Smith made the transition to linebacker and defensive end incollege, leading to one, impressive breakout season. He is raw but has the athleticism, speed to power off the edge. He has versatility and 3-4 outside linebacker potential but projected as a Day 2 pick. He is explosive, working best when he has ample room to build up speed and drive with his upper hands after his lower body generates the required force. With an ideal frame for a 3-4 outside linebacker, he has room to add bulk. He lacks lateral flexibility and is a bit straight-lined as a rusher. He must develop pass-rush skills, particularly in his lateral hand usage and body position to work as an inside-out rusher. In the run game, Smith gets by on explosiveness. He finishes well, playing away from his body with strong hands and finishing with a strong grip. His struggles at the Senior Bowl are concerning, but his speed off the edge, flashes of athleticism and breakout senior season are signs the best is yet to come for the high-upside edge rusher.

And some Tweets worth noting:

Meanwhile, Don Banks of SI.com has the Eagles taking Penn State WR Allen Robinson in the second round:

The Eagles have plenty of options and could easily take any number of available cornerbacks, but Robinson carries great value at 54 and helps offset the offseason losses Philly has suffered at receiver.

Evan Silva of Rotoworld also goes with Robinson. He has the Eagles taking Florida State safety Terrence Brooks and Florida CB Marcus Roberson in the third round.

Bucky Brooks of NFL.com has the Eagles taking Fresno State WR Davante Adams:

Adams isn't a speedster, but he is the kind of "catch-and-run" playmaker that typically thrives in Chip Kelly's system.

Rob Rang of CBSSports.com also goes with Adams:

Chip Kelly loves playmaking receivers and no one was more productive in 2013 than Adams.

Dane Brugler of CBSSports.com mocks Clemson CB Bashaud Breeland to the Eagles at 54:

Chip Kelly addressed the pass rush in the first round and might look to the secondary with this pick.

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • myeaglescantwin

    Kid’s 6’4 and long.
    he doesn’t need to be an immediate starter. He just needs to get better technique and some time in an NFL lifting program. kid could be 270 in a year hahah

    it may be a reach to some, but how many of those TV-scouts ever coached an NFL team before. If you like a player, you go get him.

  • Adam G

    Domo needs to go away

    • knighn

      So glad that Kapadia hooked up with McManus and came here. Only good thing left at Philly.com is Kempski (who took Kapadia’s spot).

  • Brian

    The more I read, the more I like. One year behind Cole, and he’ll be ready for prime time.

  • botto

    at least if it was a reach it was a reach for a pass rushing athlete that is big and fast and coachable. can’t beat that

  • UKEagle99

    I asked 2 fans which reporters comment they would like removed. Both said the same thing, Paul Domowitch.

  • Eneagled <3

    Pete Prisco is ok with this?? Now I may need to re-think how I feel about Smith

  • UKEagle99

    Two short years ago we would have traded up, given up our only 3rd rounder and have Dee Ford. All we would hear after that is about his butt, thick thighs and high motor. I like the pick.

    Next!

  • All In Eagles

    I’m not against this pick but Gruden made a good point. He was unblocked A LOT, watch the footage, he runs straight in and get the sack (huge disappointment if you miss on an unblocked sack).