Zone Read: Eagles-Cardinals, the Day After


1. What was up with the Brad Smith play in the red zone in the second quarter?

The Eagles drove to the Cardinals’ 6-yard-line when Kelly put Smith in at quarterback and split Foles out wide. Smith fumbled the snap, the offense lost 4 yards, and Alex Henery came on to kick a 32-yard field goal three plays later.

Granted, this is one of those plays where if it works, we’re all talking about what a great job Kelly did of using all his resources. And if it fails, we all second-guess.

But Foles was in a nice groove at the time. He had completed three of four passes for 63 yards on the drive. Smith just signed with the team a few weeks ago and had not had an offensive touch previously.

This probably falls in the “got too cute” category. But one thing’s for sure: Kelly is still seeking solutions for the team’s red-zone woes. For as good as the Eagles’ offense has been, they rank 29th in red-zone efficiency, scoring touchdowns just 46.15 percent of the time. The guess here is that Kelly focused on that during the bye, but he may want to throw the Smith play out the window going forward.

2. Why Kelly said the Smith play was not the wildcat?

OK, I’ll be the someone in this instance.

“It was not a wildcat play,” Kelly said. “It’s just Brad Smith plays quarterback. So let’s straighten that out right now. We don’t run the wildcat. It’s just a play. He played quarterback. Nick played receiver because Brad’s really good with the ball in his hands.”

Luckily, we have Chris Brown to explain these things to us. As Brown wrote back in 2009, wildcat plays require three things: a  mobile quarterback, the jet sweep/jet fake and an unbalanced line. The Smith play only fulfilled one of those requirements: the mobile quarterback.

The jet sweep/jet fake is when an offense motions a receiver running full speed in front of the quarterback as the ball is being snapped. The quarterback can hand the ball off to that player or fake it to him. That did not happen on the Smith play. Nobody was in motion.

And the line was not unbalanced either. The Eagles have gone with an unbalanced line on several occasions this year, but they didn’t do so on the Smith play. Therefore, Kelly wasn’t lying. This was not a wildcat play.

What was it then? It’s hard to tell for sure since Smith fumbled the snap, but it looked like just a plain old zone read. The wide receivers appeared to be blocking, so I don’t think there was a pass option. Smith was either going to hand the ball off to McCoy or keep it himself. In that respect, you can see what Kelly was going for. Why not use a more athletic option at QB if you’re going to run the zone read down there?

I still don’t agree with the call, but you can get a better idea of Kelly’s thought process.



Brandon Graham had a pair of sacks on Carson Palmer Sunday afternoon.

“He stands back there. He’s not a threat to run,” Graham said. “But we certainly made sure we collapsed the pocket. We wanted to disrupt him a little bit.”

Let’s look at Graham’s second sack. The Eagles blitzed Patrick Chung off the edge, but Graham initially gets double-teamed.



The Eagles ran a stunt, and the left tackle switched off of Graham to help on Fletcher Cox. With the running back accounting for Chung, that freed Graham up for a one-on-one matchup against the tight end.


Coverage was good, Palmer held the ball, and Graham finished.


“We called a stunt play,” Graham said. “Pretty much, they let me go free a couple times. I mean, both sacks. And it was the same call. I’m happy because the back end had to be doing their job, and my hat’s off to them because without them doing their job, I wouldn’t get the sack.”

Graham got credit for the sack. But without Chung blitzing, Cox occupying two defenders and the back end holding up in coverage, he wouldn’t have had a shot.



7 – The number of sacks by Eagles outside linebackers in the past two games. Graham and Trent Cole had two apiece vs. Arizona. In the win over the Redskins, Cole and Connor Barwin combined for three.

Through the first 10 games, the three outside linebackers had combined for just five sacks total. Now that number is up to 12. Cole suddenly leads the team with five, Barwin has four and Graham has three.

The 3-4 requires its outside linebackers to be prolific pass-rushers. This is still an area that needs to be addressed in the offseason, but the pressure the Eagles put on Palmer was critical to the defense’s success. Maybe they have just taken advantage of a couple of favorable matchups, but it’ll be a huge boost for Billy Davis’ defense if the outside linebackers can continue to progress in terms of rushing the passer down the stretch.



The rookie had his best game of the season, finishing with five catches for 68 yards and two touchdowns on six targets.

“We saw a lot of man-to-man coverage from the safety,” Ertz said. “And we’ve been working hard all year to have our number called in a big game like this, and fortunately we made some plays.”

Ertz’s most impressive catch was a 22-yarder in the first quarter. Foles had to throw the ball high to keep it away from linebacker Daryl Washington, who cut in front of the tight end. Ertz showed good concentration and good hands to reach up and snatch the ball out of the air for a big gain.

He now has seven catches of 20+ yards on the season.


The veteran failed to notch a single sack through the Eagles’ first eight games. He now has five in the last four, including a pair against the Cardinals.

Asked what the difference has been, Cole said: “Anybody should know, playing eight years as a D-End, in the ninth year you’re playing outside linebacker. That’s a big jump because now you’ve gotta be in coverage, you’ve gotta drop back. I feel like as a D-End, you’re born to run straight ahead.”

I asked Barwin if he ever sensed frustration from Cole earlier in the season.

“I’m sure he was when he went home or inside his own head,” Barwin said. “But one of the best parts about Trent is he never brought it into our meeting room. He never brought it in the locker room. He just kept his head down and kept going to work. And how he’s got five with a month left. And that’s good to see that happen – when a guy doesn’t go in the tank or start complaining about the system or start complaining about the calls. He just kept doing his job, and it’s paying off for him.”



1 2 3 4< Previous Next >View as One Page

Around The Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • hillbillybirdsfan

    Love the way Trent busted his butt to make the position change. He’ll never be a great cover guy but it’s nice to see him get rewarded for his efforts. As usual, a great job by Sheil and Tim on the post-game coverage.

  • BlockingBack-BeanCounter

    Hands Down! In the No-22, looks like Graham is lined up as a 4-3 down lineman when he gets the sack. In the Numbers That Matter, credit Graham as a DE not as an OLB.

    • Adam

      Doesn’t look like his hand is down to me. Either way, our base defense is a 3-4 and Graham is an OLB.

    • PhilliePhanCT .

      Kendricks is blocking your view. Graham is squatting down low and it appears as if he’s a down lineman.

  • JettMartinez

    If the Smith play was just a Zone Read, why keep Foles in at WR? Why not just put Smith (or Vick for that matter) in with regular personnel? At first I though it would be some kind of lateral to Foles, who would then throw a forward pass, but if the revievers were all run blocking, that doesn’t make much sense.

    • anon

      so you don’t have to sub on next play.

      • Andy124

        Also, so they don’t know it’s coming before you line up.

      • JettMartinez

        Ah! Good point, still getting used to the go go go mentality!

        • anon

          Yeah the Go-Go makes it more likely that gimmicks will work b/c D has less time to prepare. Not a terrible thing to try on 1st and goal.

  • PhilliePhanCT .

    Nice how Roc C. comes in for 2 plays and one of them is a PI that places the ball on the one. Thanks, bro. Nicely done, now…get off the field. Ugh. Kid has some upside, but you gotta know your time and place.


    Love this teams mentality. They don’t rest on their laurels, every week they seem more concerned with what they need to improve on, then patting themselves on the back….if you hear an eagle give praise! it’s praise for how a team mate played. you don’t even hear players talk about themselves. Coaching and Locker room is a major part of success…and we seem STRONG in both areas….really enjoying this season no matter how it plays out

  • Scott J

    Chung was terrible. Hopefully we’ll get Wolff back soon.

    • bentheimmigrant

      It’s like he’s blocking for the other team! That’s 2 TDs in 2 games because he’s tackled the wrong guy. Then he almost knocked Sconces out of the game.

      • cliff henny

        thought c-wills was going to knock chung out, he looked pissed. friendly fire chung

        • BlindChow

          Maybe they promote Coleman or Anderson. Surely they couldn’t be worse…?

        • theycallmerob

          the No-Man’s Landshark?

    • Scott J

      Now we know why he was benched by the Patriots. They were probably scared he might get a hit on Brady while he was standing on the sideline.

  • distantfires

    Thought Nate Allen was active throughout and had a solid game.

  • greenblood20

    Good solid win against a good, solid team. Need to finish better, obviously. Still shaking my head over the Brad Smith play on 1st down in the red zone. What were they thinking, honestly? It is like Andy Reid leapt into Chip Kelly’s body on that one…

    • EaglePete

      I thought same thing although to be fair, Smith just keep your eyes on the snap and stay within yourself there and it might get a few yards or at least work to a degree. Was totally on him, he took his eyes off the ball. Also, some of the run calls on 2nd and 17 at one point and an entire series that went 3 n out, 3 straight runs. Nit picking though.

  • theycallmerob

    Celek and Ertz combined have 14 rec of 20+ yds (7 each). combined, that ties the Eagles TEs with Vernon Davis and Jimmy Graham for most in NFL (2nd best “team” duo overall; Gates and Green in SD have 18).
    Love it, especially from a run-first team. both guys are blocking well too

  • theycallmerob

    with both ILBs back and healthy, can you tell us who’s wearing the helmet mic on that side of the ball? I assume that same person is making the calls? I thought it was Kendricks in TC and PS (being groomed for the spot), then it appeared Ryans took over (DL mention he makes the calls, and of course Kendricks missed some time).
    Just thought it was interesting Kendricks is in there for the dime package.

    also, slight typo– under the snap counts, where you mention all the players who were in 100%, you left Chung’s name off the list

    • anon

      It’s gotta be Ryans — Billy D has said as much.

      • theycallmerob

        I believe so too. Reckon Kendricks manages only the dime package

    • OldDocRoss

      ” under the snap counts, where you mention all the players who were in 100%, you left Chung’s name off the list”

      On at least a couple of snaps he was playing for Arizona, so doesn’t count.

  • jon h

    Great article Sheil.

  • OldDocRoss

    Jason Kelce consistently gives some of the most honest, intelligent post-game interviews around. One of the best things about this site is Sheil and Tim taking the time to seek out guys like Kelce rather than just speaking to the ‘name’ players.

  • maxm98

    My problem with our 4th quarter scheme is this:
    Our offense is based around numbers – 6 or less in the box = run the ball – 7 or more = pass it. We have no power running game as such.

    Yet in the fourth when we have a lead teams know we will run and yet we run anyway. We either need to stick with our philosophy and throw in the fourth or start running true power football. Otherwise this will cost us a game soon.

    • Scott J

      I understand Kelly saying he wants to run because if you throw and don’t catch the ball, the clock will stop, BUT…I think 3-and-outs are worse. First downs are more important than the clock. Besides, if we throw, the defense will have to back off from stacking the box. Sometimes Kelly reminds me of Reid where they think they’re the smartest guy in the room.

  • theycallmerob

    Great stat, courtesy of Kempski (link to the article for the explanation below)

    In reality, the Eagles are 10 of 13 (76.9%) in the red zone with Nick Foles, not 10 of 17. That would put them at 2nd in the NFL, behind only Denver.

    • Andy124

      He must have seen my post about redzone kneel downs de-yeasting Nick’s redzone %. I love this power I have.

      Thank you for sharing that. I don’t check twitter enough.

    • Joe from Easton

      Thank you, I was going to ask about this if someone hadn’t already brought it up.

  • europeaneagle

    Well I guess that means Cole is still my favorite player on defense, with Fletcher Cox not far behind. I was wearing my #58 Jersey to watch the game, seemed to work well for him. Does that mean I have to get Chung’s?