State Of the Eagles’ Roster: Offense

Zach ErtzThe Eagles begin preseason play Friday night against the Patriots, so now is as good a time as any to get a handle on the state of the roster.

This post can serve as a primer on what to watch for on offense. We’ll roll out the defense on Friday.

QUARTERBACKS

Michael Vick will get the start, but Nick Foles will rotate in with the first team. Both guys are expected to play only in the first quarter, but that could change, depending on how the possessions play out.

If you want one man’s opinion, Vick is the favorite, but it’s not like he’s been head-and-shoulders above Foles. Neither has been making quick decisions on a consistent basis, and there have been too many plays in practice that end with the whistle blowing and the ball still in the quarterback’s hands (or the QB scrambling).

Whichever QB wins the job will need time to adjust to a brand new offense, and growing pains are to be expected. All summer long, Chip Kelly has emphasized the importance of preseason games, pointing out that it’s tougher to play the position when you face the possibility of being hit. But that has probably been overstated, considering each guy is only going to play a couple series’.

The final decision will be based on a combination of factors: last year’s film, practice performance and preseason performance. Remember, if Kelly loved Foles, he wouldn’t have brought Vick back. If he loved Vick, he would have fielded trade offers for Foles. Add in the fact that the Eagles drafted Matt Barkley, and it’s clear the team was hedging its bets, hoping someone would emerge.

Speaking of Barkley, he is expected to play the second and third quarters Friday night. The rookie has not received any first-team reps and seems like a longshot to get into the starting QB competition. But things can change if he impresses during game action.

RUNNING BACKS

LeSean McCoy has missed practice time with a knee issue, and it’s unclear whether he’ll play Friday night, although the guess is he won’t.

The competition for the No. 2 job, though, has picked up. Bryce Brown flashed his unique blend of size and speed in 2012. While Brown’s looked good for the most part at camp (minus several drops as a receiver), it’s been Chris Polk who has really stood out. An undrafted free agent in 2012, Polk shed 15 pounds this offseason and looks quick and decisive. The coaches have taken notice and bumped Polk up to the first team with McCoy out.

Look for both Polk and Brown to mix in with the starters Friday night. They will be competing for playing time in their second years.

Felix Jones and Matthew Tucker, meanwhile, are fighting for roster spots.

WIDE RECEIVERS

This has become an area of concern in recent weeks. As things currently stand, Riley Cooper is the favorite to start opposite DeSean Jackson.

Jackson has looked tremendous this summer, and Kelly praised the speedy wide receiver for coming into camp in great shape. By all accounts, he is expected to have a prominent role in this offense.

Cooper got a shot at extended playing time in the final seven games of last season, but was unimpressive, averaging just 29.4 yards. But he is one of the better blocking wide receivers on the roster and can make plays in the red zone.

A lot of uncertainty deeper down the roster. Jason Avant is expected to stick as the slot guy. Damaris Johnson has had a good camp and showed good YAC ability last year, but he’s dealing with a hamstring injury. Same goes for undrafted free agent Russell Shepard, who has also had a good camp. It’s unclear whether either will play Friday night. Johnson seems like a good bet to make the team. And Sheppard is in position to earn a spot if he continues to play well.

Fans love Ifeanyi Momah’s size, but he seems raw and hasn’t made a lot of plays at camp. Momah seems more likely to land on the practice squad than to contribute. But he’ll have opportunities Friday night. Greg Salas will have a tough time sticking, but he’s had some impressive moments at camp and could potentially steal a spot with a strong preseason.

TIGHT ENDS

Zach Ertz has been as good as advertised. The guess here is that he’ll end the season with more catches and receiving yards than Brent Celek or James Casey. Ertz has had some drops, but he’s also made some great catches. He’s lined up out wide a lot in the last two weeks.

Celek has been steady, but Ertz figures to take away a chunk of his targets. Casey has had some bad drops too, but that doesn’t seem like much of a concern, considering he only dropped two passes in the last two seasons with the Texans, per Pro Football Focus.

The top three tight end spots are obviously accounted for, and the offense is expected to utilize several two-TE sets.. If the Eagles keep a fourth, the battle will come down to Clay Harbor, Derek Carrier and Emil Igwenagu.

TACKLE

Allen Barbre and Lane Johnson will start at left and right tackle, respectively, on Friday night. Jason Peters is dealing with a hamstring issue, but looked great when healthy.

Barbre spent most of camp at guard, but began playing tackle this week. With Dennis Kelly sidelined for at least the rest of the preseason (back surgery), the Eagles need depth at this spot. And Barbre has put himself in excellent shape to make the roster.

Ed Wang is dealing with a knee issue. Michael Bamiro seems more likely to contribute in future years than in 2013. Matt Kopa and Matt Tobin will need to surprise for a chance to stick around.

Friday will be our first chance to see Johnson, the No. 4 overall pick, in game action.

GUARD/CENTER

There aren’t any questions with the starters: Evan Mathis (LG), Jason Kelce (C) and Todd Herremans (RG). But backup spots are up for grabs.

We mentioned Barbre above. He’s in the mix as a backup guard too. Danny Watkins looks more comfortable this summer, but the former first-rounder will have to prove himself in game situations. With a solid preseason, he should earn a roster spot.

The backup center job is up for grabs between Dallas Reynolds, Julian Vandervelde and Matt Tennant. Reynolds has experience from last year, but the others could steal a spot.

Friday will be the first time we see Kelce in game action since he tore his ACL during Week 2 of the 2012 season.

Follow Sheil Kapadia on Twitter and e-mail him at skapadia@phillymag.com.
Become a fan of Birds 24/7 on Facebook.

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • Scott J610

    When you have two quarterbacks, you have none.

    • Johnny Domino

      If you have three you’ve got a real problem, so I am looking forward with limited expectations to see how Barkley performs.

  • Broadcasting Wisdom

    Riley Cooper will easily double his 30 yard/game average and touchdown rate now that a decent O-Line is protecting the QB, bringing him to a total of 960 yards and 8 touchdowns on the season.

    • Adam

      If he could step up and put up those numbers that would be great, would go a long way in filling the void left by Maclin.

      • Andy124

        In all nonseriousness, if Cooper puts up those numbers while filling in for Cooper, that will be the greatest accomplishment ever.

        (Playing, I know you meant filling in for Maclin).

  • JamesDDl

    Good to see Barbre filling in for JP – we get to see if he is for real and it keeps the other 4 guys in their proper positions.
    Great to see Polk & Brown with the #1 O-line, we know what Shady can do.
    Very interested to see how the TE’s are used and who will do what.
    Finally some questions will be answered. . .
    . . . the D on the other hand . . .

  • cliff henny

    all i ever read is how well g salas is doing and each writer, like sheil, says right afterwards how he’ll have trouble sticking. definitely one of the guys i’m watching for tomorrow. figure the 53 will hold 6 wrs, dress 5 gameday. seems like he’s right in mix for 5/6 slot.

    • jtre

      I agree. looks like the top 4 spots are locked up (Jackson, Avant, Johnson, and Cooper) Salas, Sheppard, and Momah are fighting for those last 2 with the loser going to the PS.

      • Johnny Domino

        Is Salas PS eligible?

      • Dilwala_G

        From the coverage, seems like Momah is the odd-man out. PS might make sense for him too (assuming he doesn’t get snatched by another team) since he’s been away from football for 2 years – time to get sharp and develop without spotlight

    • Richaud Jeaffreson

      I think they only keep 5 WR. I think they go heavy at TE, and RB. 4 of each. If you want to keep 9 OL, you can’t hang on to WR’s like that. It isn’t like the talent pool is super deep. This is what I think the 53 man roster looks like on Offense:

      QB: Foles, Vick, Barkley
      RB: McCoy, Polk, Brown, Tucker
      TE: Celek, Casey, Ertz, Harbor
      WR: Jackson, Cooper, D. Johnson, Avant, Shepard
      OL: Peters, Mathis, Kelce, Herremans, Johnson, Barbre, Tennant, Watkins, Kelly

      Only way they keep 6 WR is if they drop to 3 RB’s and put Tucker on the PS. If they do that, Salas sticks.

      • Token

        I dont think they keep 4 RBs on the 53. Its not like Jones or Tucker are special. If one of the 3 RBs gets injured you just brings Tucker back off the street or PS.

        I could see 6 WRs. I think theyd like to keep Salas and Shepard. Momah is a practice squad guy.

  • Andy124

    Waiting until game time tomorrow is going to kill me.

  • Kuney

    The preseason games will obviously dictate whats happening at QB but do you remember seattle last year? Russell Wilson beat our Matt Flynn by the first game.

    Foles has none of that hype surrounding him and he kind of needs it to beat out the experienced veteran who is the defacto leader of the team and more athletic.
    Switching series will only stagnate the offense and make it tougher to separate from each other.

    Our QB of the future is not here unless Barkley makes a jump next year or whenever Vick is no longer on the roster and the QB competition opens up again.
    Calling this a competition at this point is a sham and now a waste of reps for the 1s.

  • Chippah

    I can’t wait to see Shady and Brown/Polk run this play: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=PMGT9C43iUk

  • Rick H

    Sheil very good article. I can see the Eagles keeping four or even five tight ends. That is because the Wide receivers are not deep. After Jackson, Cooper,Avant & Johnson the rest are toss ups. With Kelly he could easily use Ertz as a slot wide receiver on a regular basis. He then becomes or takes the 5th spot if you will. Then Casey, Celek, Carrier & Harbor. Why not? Kelly loves big guys and he also likes to run the ball plus he stresses all receivers MUST BLOCK! Tight ends are all better blockers.
    The NFL is a game of mismatches and the Eagles have eliminated the fullback position essentially (that will be Casey) so the Eagles load up with size and blocking instead of a 5th receiver. I like the idea. I recognize the problem with this theory is “speed”.
    Jackson & Johnson then what? I see that side of it as well but I still would take my chances with the tight ends. Plus I would keep four running backs. McCoy, Brown, Polk & Jones (kick returner as well/good blocker in passing game/good receiver). I see a lot of mismatches with the tight ends & running backs which will favor the Eagles in games.

  • http://abigbuttandasmile.com/ A Big Butt and a Smile

    The wide receiver battle will be fun to watch. Secretly I find that much more interesting than the QB one. Looking for big things out of Shepard and Salas. Momah you’ve disappointed me baby. I’m gonna have to break up with you.

  • http://abigbuttandasmile.com/ A Big Butt and a Smile

    Oh and I want to see if all this special teams work has paid off. He (Kelly) definitely spent a lot of time working with them.

  • 1NationUnderChippah

    How has Lane Johnson looked? Things seem to be very quiet regarding how he has looked so far. I’m still bitter at Miami for jumping ahead of us and landing Dion Jordan, so I’m really hoping it works out for the best for us and I’m pulling for Johnson to be an impact tackle in Philly for year to come.. Given his overall lack of experience playing tackle, I don’t expect him to make a major impact immediately. However, I’d love to hear so positive chatter but I really haven’t. How’s he looking??

  • EAGLE WEST

    Josh Johnson is perfect for Chip……HELLO!

  • Dilwala_G

    Sheil – who do you think wins last roster spot for offense (assuming 25 for O, 25 for D, 3 ST) – a fourth RB, fourth TE, fourth QB, or sixth WR?

  • Damien

    Tobin>Barbre any day of the week.

    • Richaud Jeaffreson

      Not really. Tobin is raw, and more of a project, plus he is strictly a tackle. Barbre can play G and T, and apparently has been turning heads in camp. It is important to have guys that can play multiple positions on the line. Think of where we would have been the last couple years if Herremans couldn’t slide out and play RT.

  • Brent E. Sulecki

    I like what Salas brings. and even more so when G Cobb calls training camp action and says Salad with the nice catch on the sideline. need more of that. and Bruce Brown

  • Kuney

    how could he?

  • Scott J610

    Kuney…You’re talking about starters and a backups. We have neither. My original comment was based on Hockey. “When you have two goalies you have none.” It’s not meant to be so literal. It means the two aren’t good enough to win the starting job.

  • Kuney

    i liked both garth snow and ron hextall….

  • Scott J610

    LOL.

  • Dilwala_G

    Interesting. I was thinking that Shephard/Salas were a better last roster spot (as 6th WR) than Jones/Tucker at RB or Carrier/Harbor at TE. Maybe that’s warped a bit though by the fact that all the practice coverage is of passing drills?

  • All In Eagles

    I’m hearing the same thing in each article. It’s like the secret club and no matter how well he does he won’t get in. The guy is lighting up practices so far and he’s to be cut in the eyes of every writer. He’s also no small bean, so it’s not as if we would be carrying 3 small receivers. I loved the Momah idea but he doesn’t look like he’s even close to ready to contribute from the practice recaps. Just looks nervous and bobbles passes and can’t turn his body smoothly.

  • Richaud Jeaffreson

    I like Salas. Apparently the Pats were pretty upset about losing him off of their PS. Any player that Bellichick likes is good enough for me.

  • Richard Colton

    not sure that Tucker even deserves practice squad consideration. Tennant hasn’t stood out either – is he the best we can do at backup center?