Eagles Wake-Up Call: The Key Question With Chip Kelly

Three weeks from today, Chip Kelly’s Oregon Ducks will take on Kansas State in the Fiesta Bowl.

And not long after that, we’ll find out if Kelly’s ready to make the leap to the NFL.

We’ve written about Kelly often in this space (don’t forget to check out our special Coaching Buzz section), but recently, a couple guys with unique perspectives offered thoughts on whether he would be successful at the next level.

The first is Penn State’s Bill O’Brien. O’Brien spent five years on the Patriots’ coaching staff before taking over the Nittany Lions’ program. He has NFL experience. He has college experience. And he’s also known Kelly for a long time.

In a recent piece by Ivan Maisel of ESPN.com, O’Brien pointed out that NFL owners don’t want their quarterbacks taking the hits that are often required in Kelly’s spread attack. But that doesn’t mean he thinks Kelly would be a flop.

“Chip’s one of the brightest coaches I’ve ever spoken to, and that says a lot, because I’ve been around a lot of smart coaches,” O’Brien told Maisel. “If he ends up in the NFL, he’ll adapt his system to the type of people he has.”

That’s actually a key issue. I’m of the belief that flexibility is a key attribute in a potential new coach. Evaluating personnel is an imperfect science. And injuries will always be a factor. Putting a scheme in place and trying to force players to do things they’re not capable of often results in failure. Adjusting scheme to personnel is as important a quality as there is for an NFL head coach.

Which makes what David Shaw had to say especially intriguing. The Stanford coach beat Kelly and the Ducks, 17-14, earlier this season. But Oregon hung 53 on the Cardinal in a 2011 victory.

“It would take an organizational commitment,” Shaw, who spent nine years as an NFL assistant, told Maisel of Kelly’s spread offense. “Everybody from top to bottom, the GM, the owner, the personnel people, need to be on a mission to give that offense what it needs. You can’t waver from it. Everybody needs to be on the same page. It can’t be, ‘Well, let’s bring this receiver in.’ If he doesn’t fit their offense, they can’t bring him in. It’s so different than [what] most people are used to.”

The two stances reflect an important question that general managers and owners will have to ask themselves when weighing Kelly as a serious candidate. Are you bringing him in because you love his offense and think it could work in the NFL? Or are you bringing him in because you believe he’s a great football mind who will be able to figure things out at the pro level, and replicate the success he’s had in college?

If it’s the former, you’re looking at a high-risk, high-reward proposition. Kelly’s offense could flop, and if you’re a GM, that could very well mean you’ll be looking for work very soon. If it’s the latter, you still could fail, but you’re basing your decision on much more sound reasoning.

WHAT YOU MISSED

Mike Patterson’s agent is not happy with the Eagles for docking the remaining $150,000 of his contract. Tim’s got the details.

An early mock draft, plus a lot of love for Nick Foles. Here’s a roundup of what the national media are saying about the Eagles.

Perhaps people are talking about the wrong Gruden. T-Mac takes a look at the prospects of Jay, the Bengals’ offensive coordinator, becoming a head coach.

LeSean McCoy and Michael Vick have officially been ruled out for tonight’s game.

An All-22 look at what the Eagles’ defense looked like without Jim Washburn last week.

Will Foles answer the skeptics tonight?

WHAT THEY’RE SAYING

Peter Schrager of FoxSports.com predicts a 27-17 Bengals victory:

If this is Andy Reid’s last season in Philadelphia, his Eagles team — led by unlikely heroes Nick Foles, Jason Avant and Riley Cooper — sure gave him one sweet win to remember from his 2012 campaign on Sunday. Inspired and undaunted, the Eagles came back from a 21-10 deficit to beat Tampa Bay on the final play of the game on the road last week. Four days later, I’d love to rally around this “Win one for Andy” thing and pick the Eagles, but even the most inspired rallying cry in the world can’t stop Geno Atkins in the middle. The Eagles’ offensive line struggles with mediocre defensive tackles on a regular basis. Atkins may be the league’s best.

Pete Prisco of CBSSports.com also has Cincinnati winning, 24-17:

This is a must-win for the Bengals coming off their disappointing loss to the Cowboys. Nick Foles looked good last week against the Bucs, but the Bengals front is much better than Tampa Bay’s. That will be a factor here. Also, look for A.J. Green to bounce back with a big game.

COMING UP

We’ll get you ready for tonight’s matchup and then be live-chatting the action, starting at 8 p.m.

Follow Sheil Kapadia on Twitter and e-mail him at skapadia@phillymag.com.
Become a fan of Birds 24/7 on Facebook.

  • 1972

    Sheil
    if they bring kelly here it would be a roseman move , and a disaster.Why is he the hot name out there anyway? he hasnt won anything, how innovative is his offense really?If you dont have a running QB it doesnt work at all.This’ll be the im smarter than everyone else pick. Pick a hungry coordinator already in the league PLEASE

    • FMWarner

      I’m skeptical of Kelly as an NFL coach, but how can you say he hasn’t won anything? All he does is win.

      • johngiam

        win what? that flag football conference?

        • FMWarner

          Yeah, same “flag football” conference that produced a couple of NFL Coach of the Year candidates you may have heard of, Pete Carroll and Jim Harbaugh.

  • southy

    “Putting a scheme in place and trying to force players to do things they’re not capable of often results in failure.”

    I think we’ve learned that all too well in Philly. I don’t mind the idea of bringing in Kelly to see if he can bring some new ideas, but you’re not going to be able to run an NCAA offense in the NFL, and he needs to be humble enough to admit that before you write him a check.

  • The Guru

    Chip Kelly is an organizational melt down waiting to happen. His offense has no chance of working in the NFL….and we’re going to have to draft players specific for his system. So once it fails, which is almost a certainty, then we’re stuck trying to rebuild an offense with players that aren’t optimal for the next coach.

    Not to mention, have you watched Chip Kelly’s defenses over the last 5 years? He might as well not even field a defense.

    This is going to work as well as Steve Spurrier and his “gimmick” offense.

    • JohnGiam

      haha I take flack all the time on this site saying what a moronic decision it would be to hire chip or saban………. i dont even understand how anyone could consider chip kelly. havent we seen enough gimicky football with soft defense? line the FOCK up and punch someone in the mouth for once!

      • The Guru

        And what the hell has Chip Kelly ever won? At least Spurrier had titles.

        I’d consider Saban, but he does play a fantastic style of football perfect for Philadelphia.

  • Pat Mc

    I think Shaw would be the best option out of the college coaches if they go that route. His system works in the NFL, since he is essentially running the same system as Harbaugh in SF. I’m leahry of Kelly’s system translating to the NFL.

  • hillbillybirdsfan

    Kelly seems like a sharp dude but he represents a greater risk, A little part of me is hoping the Bengals hang 50 on us so that Lurie is impressed with Jay Gruden. He runs the ball, got a rookie QB to the Pro Bowl and isn’t running an offense that requires us to get all new guys. I’ve had enough of the square peg/round hole moments. I am guessing Lurie is sold on Roseman or we would have at least heard rumors about us bidding on the Lombardi-Saban package that Cleveland is considering.

  • Septhinox

    “Putting a scheme in place and trying to force players to do things they’re not capable of often results in failure.”

    Impossible. Andy Reid did it and he’s smarter than us all…

    Wait…