Best of Philly

Best Tomato Pie

2014 BEST Tomato Pie

Corropolese Bakery and Deli

This pie’s simplicity makes it irresistible a thick smear of sweet red sauce, an oil-rich crust and a sprinkle of parm.

2014 Old Arch Road, #2, Norristown, PA | 610-275-6664 | Website


2011 BEST Tomato Pie

Corropolese Bakery and Deli

29 Kugler Road, Limerick, PA

The fruit pies are incredible, the pastries are awesome, the soft pretzels are … available. But the tomato pie is the real star, and if the giant stack of boxed pies perennially piled up at the back counter is any evidence, we ain’t the only ones who think so. Read more »

2010 BEST Tomato Pie

Stogie Joe’s

1801 East Passyunk Avenue, Philadelphia, PA

Doughy. Tangy. Saucy. And those are just the waitresses. The tomato pie rocks, too. Read more »