Weight-Loss Surgery Better Than Dieting—Wait, What?!

Find out why experts say more folks should be going under the knife.



“All it takes is a little hard work and dedication.” I’m sure someone has said this to you at some point in your life. And sure, yes, it can apply to a great many things: learning the guitar, mastering painting, becoming an Olympic athlete. But apparently, it’s not the case when it comes to weight loss. According to HealthDay, a new study shows that weight-loss surgery is more effective than diet and exercise when it comes to shedding unwanted pounds.

The study analyzed nearly 800 people who’d either undergone weight-loss surgery or tried nonsurgical weight-loss treatments, and found that weight-loss surgery patients lost significantly more weight than the nonsurgical patients (an average of 57 pounds more) and reported greater reduction in medication use along with greater improvements in quality of life. Also, those who went under the knife had a WAY higher remission rate of type 2 diabetes—22 times higher (!!!), to be exact.

Invasive weight-loss surgery isn’t for the Regina Georges among us who “really just want to lose three pounds”; it’s for folks whose weight poses serious risks to their health. And with over two-thirds of the current U.S. population reported as overweight or obese, that applies to a LOT of people.

“Bariatric surgery is underutilized. If we were talking about any other treatment with such a striking effect on diabetes, it would be offered to patients sooner,” Dr. Mitchel Roslin, chief of obesity surgery at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York City, told HealthDay.

So, if weight-loss surgery is so effective, why aren’t more people trying it? Well, it’s expensive, for one, averaging at around $25,000. And, as with any other invasive procedure, there are risks, such as iron deficiency anemia and the need for re-operation.

Tell us, Be Wellers: Given the risks and rewards, should more people be taking advantage of surgery as a weight-loss option? Or are you sticking with Team Diet and Exercise?

Around The Web

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • Iryna Sarachman

    Truly, after fighting the bulge all my life, I would opt for the surgery.

  • Gardenhire

    I am in the process of trying to gather
    information for my wife who is stubborn and scared. Even the thought of surgery
    scares her and when she gets scared she stops listening and thinking. She is
    only 30 but she is obsess and has a long family history of obesity and many of
    the health related problems that come with the weight. Frankly this is what
    scares me the most, for I don’t want to be widowed before we have had time to
    enjoy our lives. But honestly I want her to say yes to surgery because she has tried lot of other things and they have not worked. So from the perspective of a loving husband I would say surgery is the best.

  • Talulabell

    This surgery is merely a tool only. People still have to do the work or it will not work. I had a successful liposuction in Thailand last year, the procedure was a tool for me to make sure that I am healthy, to lose the fats stored in my body. While my appearance will be altered initially, cosmetic surgery is not an alternative to maintaining a healthy diet and exercising, it cannot address lifestyle issues. It is far better to make long term lifestyle changes by eating nutritious diet and by moving more.