How to Make Your Own Halloween Candy

Don’t steal sweets from the stash you’re handing out tonight. From Reese’s to Kit Kats to Snickers and more, make your own Halloween candy at home.

The best thing about Halloween? Candy.

If you’re like me and can rarely turn down a Reese’s Cup or Almond Joy, you may be panic-stricken at the impending diet-doom of this 24-hour candy fest. To satisfy your sweet tooth (and put your mind at ease), try these recipes for better-for-you versions of popular Halloween candies made with ingredients you can actually pronounce.

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
via Dinners, Dishes, and Desserts

Much better for you than preservative-laden Reese’s cups, these homemade treats capture all of the chocolatey, peanut-buttery goodness found in a Reese’s. Add Rice Krispies or crushed nuts for an extra crunch.

Snickers
via SparkRecipes

This is an extremely healthy version of your traditional Snickers bar. Oats, honey … flaxseed? Absolutely no guilt here.

Kit Kat Bars
via Slim-shoppin.com

All you need are these three ingredients: graham crackers, peanut butter and almond-bark chocolate.

Almond Joy
via Greens and Chocolate

Good news: these are so fun to make and taste even better than the original, which happens to be my favorite candy. Bad news: it’s nearly impossible not to eat them all at once.

Twix
via FitSugar

No culinary finesse required here: Dip two graham crackers in sugar-free chocolate, “smoosh” together with caramel (and more chocolate) and … voila!

PayDay
via Healthy Indulgences

Whisk extra coconut milk into your leftover PayDay mixture until the sauce is smooth and light in color for the perfect peanut-butter dessert sauce (perfect for apple-dipping)!

Three Musketeers
via Namely Marly

These are made with only four ingredients and—bonus!—they’re 100 percent vegan to boot.

Butterfingers
via Book of Yum

Here are some of the things found in a store-bought Nestle Butterfinger: sugar, hydrogenated palm kernel oil, modified milk ingredients (what is that?), soya lecithin, artificial flavor, TBHQ, citric acid and color. In this version, you have dates, peanuts, peanut butter and nutmeg. Halloween should be scary, ingredients should not.

York Peppermint Patties
via Passionate Homemaking

A vegan twist on the minty fresh favorite. We promise you’ll still “get the sensation.”

Baby Ruth Bars
via Yummly

You’ll have to eat these quick so they don’t lose their crunch (but I’m sure that won’t be a problem). Leave off the chocolate coating for an equally delicious naked version of a Baby Ruth.

Nestlé Crunch
via Chocolate-Covered Katie

These take a total of five minutes to make. Which means in the same amount of time it takes to read through this post, you could be halfway done making your own delicious version of a Nestlé Crunch bar.

Lemon Candy Corn
via VegSpinz

To make traditional vanilla-flavored candy corn, omit the lemon. Or experiment with another extract to create your own flavor.

Tell us: What are your favorite Halloween candies? Share in the comments!

>> Get more Be Well Philly recipes and healthy-eating tips over here.

Photo: Shutterstock

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.