Web Original: Critic’s Notebook: The Price Isn’t Right

In his newly updated Wine Buyer’s Guide (out this week), wine critic Robert Parker calls for a boycott on restaurants whose exorbitant markups on wine discourage people from ordering it. While I wouldn’t go so far as boycotting any restaurants, Parker does have a point. Many times when dining out, I’ve faced wine menus stacked with familiar bottles — ones I have at home — listed at prices multiple times what I paid for them. Recently, while writing my review for 10 Arts, I was extremely frustrated by the new restaurant’s pricey wine list. At Le Bec-Fin, whose list is several pages long, I actually broke down, swallowed my pride and quietly requested a dry red under the $100 mark.

Yes, not every restaurant in Philly extracts a pound of flesh for a bottle of wine. Friday Saturday Sunday famously marks up its bottles only $10 over cost (which means ordering any bottle that costs over $10 in-store is a pretty great deal). But these benevolent gestures seem like an exception to the rule when it comes to wine prices.

With boycotting out of the question — let’s face it, we’re not going to swear off some of the city’s best restaurants — I’m wondering who knows of any other area spots with fairly priced wine lists?

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • Anonymous

    Hi! I'm not sure how they compare on a daily basis, but Derek's in Manayunk offers all their wine at half price on Sundays.

  • Pat

    Some good values on the varied list, a knowledgable staff and 50% off any wine on Monday nights!

  • virginia

    buy your wine at total wine in delaware, lower
    cost and no taxes. no brainer

  • linda

    …and the wines aren't that expensive to begin with. There are some interesting choices.