Taste: Reviews: East Meets West

The new Oyster House puts a California spin on a Philly tradition

In the early ’90s, when Sam Mink spent his days off from high school shucking oysters at Sansom Street Oyster House, his father’s restaurant, he contemplated alternative careers. By the time he finished college, he was ready to move to San Francisco, where he got a job teaching second grade. But over the years, a funny thing happened. He couldn’t get the family business out of his mind. Eventually, after five years in the classroom, Mink left teaching to attend culinary school, then went on to work at San Fran’s famous Zuni Café. “I always knew Philadelphia would come calling. I knew I would come back home,” says Mink. Oysters were in his blood.

[sidebar]When he moved back to town in 2006, Sansom Street Oyster House wasn’t Mink family-owned for the first time in decades. David Mink, Sam’s dad, sold it in 2000. Afterward, the restaurant’s reputation declined, and rumors swirled that the business wouldn’t survive. Sam Mink bided his time and gathered experience, working at Amada and Distrito, hoping he’d get the chance to bring the property back under family ownership. While he waited, he clarified his vision for the Oyster House: “I knew I wanted to expand the restaurant, raise the ceiling, open the place up.” Food-wise, he would adhere to the restaurant’s venerated traditions — snapper soup, fried oysters with chicken salad — but update them with fresher, lighter California techniques.

Following a serendipitous sale that made Mink the owner, and then a year-long renovation, the new Oyster House is just as he envisioned it. The ceilings now soar, festooned with modern industrial light fixtures and exposed ducts. Whitewashed bricks, glossy subway tile and marble bars give the dining room a clean, expansive feel. The walls are decked with the family’s collection of colorful ceramic oyster plates, a considered detail that lends a real personality palpably different from the contrived corporate identities of so many other eateries this size.

The heart of the menu, the oyster list, changes every day. It usually features five to seven varieties, with options from both coasts. Mink thought about confining the list to East Coast specimens, but his love of the Westerners, like the tiny, succulent, cucumber-scented Kumamoto, mandated that both regions be represented. Servers offer spot-on descriptions and guide newbies through the oyster-ordering process. During one visit, I fell head over heels in love with the Wellfleet from Cape Cod. My only disappointment at the raw bar was inconsistent shucking that left some oysters sullied with bits of shell and grit, especially during busy times.

THE REST OF the menu, devised by Mink and executive chef Greg Ling, sticks to the classics of the fish-house genre, but modernized recipes abound. Longtime loyalists will find their snapper soup has been made over. Gone are the flour and cornstarch, ingredients that gave the old version all the finesse of wallpaper paste. The new version is full of surprisingly beef-like turtle meat and aromatic carrots, celery and onion, with a light tomato-y top note and warm currents of allspice. The New England clam chowder has undergone a similar lightening-up; its texture is now more brothy than thick, allowing the fresh clam flavor to shine. Mink compares the fisherman’s stew to French bouillabaisse, but it reminded me more of San Francisco’s cioppino. The inspiration hardly matters, though, in a bowl of stew so delicious: head-on shrimp, mussels, scallops, calamari and bass in an oceanic broth boldly spiced with cayenne and fragrant with Pernod.

Some dishes are reaches for the genre, exhibiting the ambition usually reserved for white-tablecloth places. Striped bass served with chanterelle mushrooms, corn, asparagus and tomato vinaigrette seemed unnecessarily fussy, and its flavors didn’t harmonize as well as those in many pared-down options, like the lobster roll. A side of roasted beets with skordalia, a creamy potato-based sauce, was poorly executed, with undercooked beets and a lack of salt. The burger, an obligatory non-fish menu item, was also inadequately seasoned.

But who orders a burger at a fish house, anyway? If you let common sense be your guide, you’ll be treated to well-­executed dishes that have become classics for a reason. Even with the minor missteps and disappointments, the unmistakable flavors of quality ingredients dominate the meal. And though Mink says some old-timers miss the starchy soups, most diners will welcome his subtle tweaks, his left-coast embellishments to these East Coast standards. It’s a formula that should keep oyster addicts happy and the Mink family in business for another 60 years.       

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.

  • Lynn

    I have been a long time fan and patron. We went there last week so I could have the jumbo crab special I read about. Crabs were good but very far from jumbo. Next time I’ll call first to verify they actually have jumbo hardshells. Oysters were yummy.

  • Heather Marie

    …and have gone three times in the past 6 weeks..
    We, too, fell in love with the Wellfleets from Cape Cod, and on a later visit, thoroughly enjoyed the Royal Miyagis.
    I agree with Joy – the fish stew is delicious; the touch of cayenne is just the spice it needs.
    On an earlier visit, scallops with fresh corn and tomatoes brought summer’s tastes to a new height.
    My husband and brother-n-law got the burger one night; sure, it’s not something you’d expect to order at an Oyster House, but when you’re spending a lot on fresh oysters, something more affordable like the burger (esp. since it is topped with an exceptionally flavorful – according to them – fried oyster) works.
    On our first visit, my husband got the lobster roll, which was overflowing with perfectly-cooked lobster… perhaps better than some he’d had when he lived in Boston.

  • Angela

    i am a long time patron of Oyster house and it just feels different in there…..corporate….. i like the old staff and owners…and the low ceilings:)

  • T

    I have been a long time fan of the Oyster House. I use to stop in here on a weekly basis for the happy hour specials. Now, I don’t get here as often as I would like. I do love the Choptanks, however, the revamped Lobster Bisque recipe does not hold a candle to the previous recipe. I really like the oysters shooters as well. It’s nice to see that some of the same shuckers are still there:)I love the new renovations that were made, it’s more spacious and open. I wouldn’t say it’s ‘corporate’ I just think it’s trendier then it use then the Oyster House of yester-year.