Taste: In Search of … Rotisserie Chicken


With all the present-wrapping and family drama in your holiday future, a rotisserie chicken from the local supermarket's prepared foods section is an easy way to save some time — and sanity. We blind-tasted eight to find the best bird, rating them from 5 (your guests will never know it's store-bought) to 1 (avoid like the avian flu).

Acme, $6.99
“Plump and juicy,” with “good roasted flavor” and “dark and crispy” skin.
Rating: 5

Wegmans, $4.99
“Salty,” “greasy in a good way,” with “very good chicken flavor.” It “tastes like Mom's.”
Rating: 4

Genuardi's, $6.99
“Buttery flesh” and “sweet, sticky, crispy skin,” but “slightly over-seasoned.”
Rating: 4

Super Fresh, $5.99
“Decent, well-spiced flavor but very gristly and fatty,” and the “skin is not crisp enough.”
Rating: 3

ShopRite, $5.99
“Needs a flavor boost.” There's “not enough seasoning” and a “slight chemical flavor.” “Meat is a bit mealy.”
Rating: 2

Trader Joe's, $4.99
“Gummy meat” and “slimy skin.” And it's “way too salty.”
Rating: 1

Whole Foods, $8.99
“Completely dried-out meat. The flesh actually crumbles,” and there's “no flavor whatsoever.”
Rating: 1

Pathmark, $5.99
With an “off, fishy flavor,” it “doesn't taste like chicken.”
Rating: 1

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.