Taste: Ideas: Too Comfortable

The March “How America Eats” issue of Bon Appetit spotted a new trend for 2005: Comfort food is in. Most of the magazine’s picks are implausible: “Artisanal food” is in, as though next year Bon Appetit could possibly claim that it’s out, while “mass-produced, poor-quality ingredients from corporate factories” are in. But among permanent food trends, comfort food has a remarkable place: Not only is it always in, but journalists seem intent on always declaring it a new phenomenon. In Philadelphia, comfort food seems — like most things—to be whatever Stephen Starr says it is at a given time. His nouveau diner Jones opened in 2002 boasting of a “comfort food menu.” The mashed potatoes shoveled onto a plate there are, it seems, comforting. The wasabi mashed potatoes at Buddakan, the lobster mashed potatoes at Continental, and the $9 whipped potato side at Barclay Prime are apparently designed without the diner’s repose in mind. Old City’s Farmacia opened late last year as a mishmash of motifs — medicinal, agricultural, Asian — but a press release summed up the jungle as "traditional comfort foods."

The comfort-food trend may be food journalism’s laziest trope. “Comfort food is in vogue,” the San Diego Union-Tribune declared in early 2000; however, the Las Vegas Review-Journal later proposed that the trend started after September 11th. In 1999, the New York Times proclaimed a “trend” that “comfort food is more popular than ever.” In its FoodTRENDS ’96 report, the Thomas Food Industry Register, a trade publication, included a comfort-food boom. Why was comfort food taking off in 1996? Sixteen percent of those surveyed said it was “because they are tired of ‘trendy’ foods.”

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.