Single in Philly: Are You There, Waffles? It’s Me, Christy

From matchmakers to Match.com, I set out to chronicle what dating in Philly is like these days. So how did my heart get involved, too?

Text Size: A | A | A
By Christine Speer

I’M LATE FOR the matchmaker. It’s only five minutes past the time we said we’d meet at a coffee shop in Center City, but every minute I keep her waiting could be one more minute I’m delaying true love. (Or so the theory goes.)

The matchmaker, Monica Mandell, is the Philly representative for a Chicago-based firm called Selective Search, and she’s a far cry from the yenta caricature I’d semi-envisioned when I set up this meeting over the phone. A petite brunette in her mid-40s, she laughs at my jokes and chats animatedly about her husband and their three kids. Even before we get down to business, I can already see why her clients — all men, all of whom can afford her base fee of $15,000 — would want someone like her on their side in the search for a soulmate.

“Our clients tend to be men who are successful in every other aspect of their lives,” she says. “At this point, they’re not looking for someone just to date. They want significant, important relationships. They want love.” And so they go to Monica, who in her former life was a psychologist, and she guides them through a two-hour interview and a 17-page questionnaire. She then searches a 50,000-person database of Selective Search women on their behalf, looking for a match.

The database women have all submitted their detailed profiles and photos for free. If Monica likes what she sees, an interview follows. And if the interview goes well, the woman is entered into a small pool of potential partners, until the right client — a potential match — comes along. For the women, it’s a win-win: The process is totally confidential, and they’re out nothing if a match never materializes. But if the right client does come along, well … It happens more often than you’d think, Monica says, smiling. She boasts a 30 percent success rate (success being clients in happy relationships) after first introductions, and 45 percent by the third try.

Okay, says a girlfriend a few days later, when I tell her about the meeting. “But $15,000? At that price, aren’t they really just buying a wife?”

I tell her — and also myself, a little — that paying someone to help you find love isn’t exactly the same as subscribing to the mail-order-bride catalog. And besides, these guys — Selective Search clients — tend to have the cash to spare.

“In Philly, they’re the Who’s Who of the city,” insists founder Barbie Adler. And Adler, a 37-year-old former headhunter for Korn/Ferry, has built a small empire around finding them life partners, running searches for matches in much the same way corporations run searches for employees.

“Isn’t that fascinating?” I say to my friend.

“Yeah,” she says. “And so romantic.”

 
 
Originally published in Philadelphia Magazine, November 2008

  • Cassie

    :D more and more love to my cousin :) i loved this article!

  • Christine
  • Bianca

    So i read this and thought of my own experiences out on the weekends, with okcupid, friends of friends and I have to say she hit home when Christy said that "dating is lonely". it can be, but this piece was charming.

  • Simone

    My Mom gave me this magazine so that I can search for men in Philly…typical I know. However, while travelling back to NY I decided to read the magazine and came across this article. I fell in love with Christine Speer as well as the article itself. I spent the trip hysterically laughing as Christine took us on her journey of dating. The friend I was traveling with kept getting updates as I would read aloud my favorite parts. Any girl who has ever done online dating, or any kind of dating these days, can identify 10000% with this author. For those who haven't had the honor of online dating…this is EXACTLY how it goes. haha. Thank you so much Christine Speer for such a wonderfully written article. It's definitely one of my favorites!!!

  • Lea

    Although I let out a big sigh by the end of reading this article, the saving grace is the feeling that I am not alone in the pool of young, successful, good looking women who have trouble finding soul mates in Philadelphia. I read your article out loud, like a bed time story, to my recently single roommate last Friday night as we curled up to watch a movie together. I thought she might start to cry at the thought of being back in dating pool, but rather it was actually nice to not feel lonely, because we were both laughing together at how similar the author’s experiences were to my own. At the end we both said in unison that I could have written this article without even being paid!

    Last summer my best friend and I went on a quest to date. We did match.com and 8-minute dating (at the Blue Martini too – what a gross bar!). We also dated people we met on our own and through friends. Some feedback for anyone thinking about a dating quest: I totally agree with the author that the drawb