Performance Review: Pig Iron’s (Not So) Sweet By-and-By

Barely recovered from The European Lesson — a jolly fun play that disintegrated (and left me quite discombobulated) into a Sigur Ros video ("Untitled #1," aka "Vaka") — did I enter The Arts Bank, whereupon another Scandinavian collaboration awaited me, this one from Philadelphia’s beloved Pig Iron Theatre Company …

The Sweet By-and-By
By Pig Iron Theatre Company and Daniel Rudholm of Teater Sláva
Starring Daniel Rudholm

Strengths … All of the elements are there for a good show: a sparse, rustic stage set onto which beautiful animations are projected; a gifted actor; songs (everybody likes songs, right?); the promising story of a bygone rabble-rousing, unionizing, banjo-playing, rile-’em-up songster; and Pig Iron — which the New York Times described as “one of the few groups successfully taking theatre in new directions” — at the helm, no less.

Weaknesses … The songs, at a point, are tedious (when Rudholm observed the audience in need of cheering up, he asked, "How about a song?" after which my companion grasped my arm in sheer panic and whisper-pleaded "No!"), as is the overwritten and disengaging script. Daniel Rudholm, the one man in this one-man show, is an obvious talent, yet said talent is all but wasted in this non-story. 

Verdict … Perhaps this was just a labor of love (otherwise why the hell would they put it up?). Or maybe it’s just time that the highly reputable and respected Pig Iron had a miss. You’ll wish that time would fly, rather than crawl, by and by.

Through Saturday, September 13th, at the Arts Bank

Be respectful of our online community and contribute to an engaging conversation. We reserve the right to ban impersonators and remove comments that contain personal attacks, threats, or profanity, or are flat-out offensive. By posting here, you are permitting Philadelphia magazine and Metro Corp. to edit and republish your comment in all media.