Departments Article

Loco Parentis: Living Large

Why do boys get to be as big as they want?

By Sandy Hingston

Illustration by Jason Schneider

Page 1 of 5

My son, Jake, has finished supper. He carries his plate to the sink, gets a bowl from the cupboard, finds the ice-cream scoop in the silverware drawer, and takes a brand-new half-gallon of Rocky Road from the freezer. Humming to himself, he pries open the lid, applies the scoop, and drops a huge mound of ice cream in his bowl. He repeats the process once, then twice. Then he returns the ice cream to the freezer, opens the fridge, gets out a canister of whipped cream, and squirts hefty snowcaps onto his Rocky Road mountain range.

He sees me looking. “What?” he demands.

“Nothing,” I say, but he hears the disapproval.

“Is it too much?”

“A serving’s half a cup.”

“Do you want me to put some back?”

“You can’t put it back now. It’s covered in whipped cream.”

“Why don’t I just throw it out?” he says fiercely, moving toward the trash. But he stops before he dumps it in. He knows this dance.

“Never mind,” I say. “Go ahead and eat it. But next time, remember: half a cup.”

“Right,” he says, and heads out into the living room, to his computer desk. He’s humming again.

Food makes my son happy, on what seems to be a cellular level. Tacos, spaghetti and meatballs, stuffed peppers — these are his favorite things. Macaroni and cheese is his Xanax, General Tso’s chicken his ecstasy. On the downside …

“Is that eggplant?” he’ll demand, staring into the wok as I stir-fry veggies.

“A small eggplant. A tiny eggplant. And the pieces are big, so you can pick them out.”

“I hate eggplant.” He’s in a funk for the rest of the night. And I can’t say I blame him. When it comes to food, my son takes after me. Our tastes are simple. But our appetites are vast.


AN HORS D’OEUVRE: I had normal-size parents, and my three siblings are normal-size. Me, I’m plus. Except for a few brief stretches like the run-up to my wedding, I always have been. This was a source of great consternation to my mom and dad, who shamed, cajoled and bribed me well into adulthood to lose weight. I swore to myself that when I had kids, I’d never, ever say anything to them about their size. I didn’t want food to be a battleground. I wanted it to be sustenance.

And this was fairly easy, in the beginning. After all, with babies, you want them to eat. To a new parent, size equals strength. Infants need cushioning, in case your suburb’s struck by cholera or plague. But by the time Jake’s older sister Marcy got to middle school, I was starting to worry. She was big like me; there wasn’t any denying it. Fortunately — unfortunately — society was on her like a leech to get skinny, so I didn’t have to say a word. By 10th grade, she was Kate Moss-thin. I was impressed by her self-control — until her hair began to fall out in clumps. With the help of a therapist, she conquered her eating disorder. But now I was totally confused on what messages to send my kids about food. Of course I wanted Marcy healthy — but damn, she sure had looked good when she was thin. Except for the hair.

And then Jake got big.


 

Page | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next


Change text size
Print

Email

Write a comment
 
 

User comments

And you're a PARENT? You have GOT to be kidding me
Posted by Anonymous | Feb. 29, 2008 at 2:43 PM
COMMENT:
"I was impressed by her self-control — until her hair began to fall out in clumps." This is the problem right here in a nutshell. You want your daughter to be healthy, but she LOOKS BETTER TO YOU SICK?!?!? First of all, lady, you have drunk waaaay too much of the cultural Kool Aid without even thinking about what you're imbibing. Second, if your daughter ends up hating you, you have only yourself to blame. But I can't escape a sneaking feeling that somehow you already know that.
Well...
Posted by Anonymous | Feb. 29, 2008 at 2:47 PM
COMMENT:
"It’s something Marcy never will be able to do." Well, certainly not as long as her mother -- that would be the author -- keeps investing her with her own self-hatred, no. Marcy will never be able to do that.
Difficult psychological truths
Posted by T | Feb. 29, 2008 at 3:10 PM
COMMENT:
In response to the previous poster, there’s a famous feminist saying: “It’s hard to fight an enemy who has outposts in your head.” It seems to fit pretty well here. I think this is a moving article.
you're sick
Posted by Anonymous | Feb. 29, 2008 at 4:50 PM
COMMENT:
I feel bad for your daughter. what on earth is wrong with you? get help.
unbelievable
Posted by Anonymous | Feb. 29, 2008 at 9:02 PM
COMMENT:
"damn she sure looked good when she was thin. except her hair." is this supposed to be breezy humor? it is heartbreaking. if the author recognizes the lasting pain of her father's degrading comments about her own weight, she should have the self-awareness to not victimize her sick daughter. I hope her daughter can rise above her mother's contemptible shallowness masquerading as concern. Recovering from an eating disorder with that lack of support takes so much inner strength. When my sister was strugggling with anorexia my family were not thinking of how great she looked. We were looking into her haunted eyes of someone taken over by self-imposed restrictions and doing anything we could to help her recover and become a vibrant person again. The attitudes of this author are shameful. Therapy is in order here.
I should add
Posted by Anonymous | Feb. 29, 2008 at 9:23 PM
COMMENT:
...that I undertand and agree with the author's observation that there is a double standard saying heavy men are often respected/seen as "real men" while heavy women are subjected to much discrimination. However, people with eating disorders are never happy or fulfilled. The fact that the daughtrer is recovering for eating disorder, even if that means she isn't "kate moss thin" anymore, is a sign that her daughter has a chance to be well-adjusted again. The way to empower ones daughter is not to mirror society's obsession with weight but to focus on other qualities. To tell yourself that the only way your daughter will experience any personal liberation is to sire big-boned male children is regressive and passive. good grief.
I should add
Posted by Anonymous | Feb. 29, 2008 at 9:32 PM
COMMENT:
...that I undertand and agree with the author's observation that there is a double standard saying heavy men are often respected/seen as "real men" while heavy women are subjected to much discrimination. The many t.v. shows/films depicting "slobbish" overweight macho men with tiny, fawning wives is one depiction of that. However, people with eating disorders are never happy or fulfilled. The fact that the daughtrer is recovering for eating disorder, even if that means she isn't "kate moss thin" anymore, is a sign that her daughter has a chance to be well-adjusted again. The way to empower ones daughter is not to mirror society's obsession with weight but to focus on other qualities. To tell yourself that the only way your daughter will experience any personal liberation is to sire big-boned male children is regressive and passive.
my mouth hit the floor
Posted by Anonymous | Mar. 5, 2008 at 9:40 AM
COMMENT:
Yes, there is a double standard for men and women. But as someone in recovery from an eating disorder when I read "but Damn she looked good, except the hair" my mouth hit the floor. No matter how long your daughter has been recovered (and I do hope she is healthy and well) how can you possibly say something like that, knowing what she went through? And hoping that your daughter has an overweight son so she can take pleasure in their size is plain twisted. I know parents don't cause their children's eating disordrs but I wouldn't be surprised if you negatively influenced your daughter's feelings about food and body image. If you haven't already, I'd talk to your daughter about how reading your article made her feel.

Post a comment

(* = required field.)
  • Please check to make sure that your referer is not blocked.


Subject line of your comment*
Your comments (200 words max)*
Email*
First name*
Last Name*
Enter the code shown below.
Visual CAPTCHA
This helps prevent automated form submissions.
Philadelphia It List

Lets Do Cocktails: Recipes

Take a sneak peak into the latest, mouth-watering cocktails that will be featured in Philadelphia's area restaurants this season.
 
 

Whiskey Festival 2009

Join us at the 2009 Whiskey Festival - a tasting event featuring premium whiskeys and spirits from around the world. November 12. 6:30pm. Union League of Philadelphia. $85. Buy Tickets Now.
 
 

Design Home 2009

Philadelphia magazine's Eighth Annual Design Home. Follow our progress and explore the details as they come to life in two magnificent carriage homes at Haverford Reserve. Tours start September 10th.
 
 

6th Annual Trailblazer Award

Do you know an accomplished business woman? Submit your nomination today for Philadelphia magazine's 6th Annual Trailblazer Award! Deadline is November 6.
 
 

FYI Philly

Watch FYI Philly on 6 ABC! Join hosts Karen Rogers and Adam Joseph for all things sizzling and buzzworthy. Each show includes content from the editors of Philly Mag.