Critic's Notebook: Smell Test

Posted on 7/24/08  
Text Size: A | A | A
 

When I go out on a reviewing meal, I strive to keep the situation favorable for accurate tasting and observing. I bring a companion who will follow my ordering instructions. I steer my server to the table that offers the best view of the operation. I eavesdrop on my fellow diners to gauge the crowd. And I sniff, a lot.

Because, as anyone who has ever tried to enjoy food with a stuffy nose knows, smell is 90 percent of taste. Aroma and flavor are inextricably linked. Nothing throws a bigger roadblock up during a review meal more than a nearby diner reeking of perfume or cologne. Diners are asked to follow some rules with regard to smoking and dress codes. Why not a fragrance ban as well?

The tongue-in-cheek “House Etiquette” section on the menu at Midtown Village’s Apothecary playfully remonstrates patrons whose perfumes and colognes interfere with other guests’ olfactory experience. But it’s a suggestion diners should take seriously. For the sake of your meal and mine, I beg you, refrain from fragrance when dining out. It’s enough to make garlic mashed potatoes taste like they’ve been seasoned with rosewater.

Originally published on phillymag.com on July 24, 2008.
 

Current Issue


User Comments:

No users have posted comments on this article.
Philadelphia It List

Philadelphia Wine Festival 2010

The Philadelphia Wine Festival is back for its 9th year! This premier tasting event boasts nearly 200 fine wineries from around the world. May 8. Philadelphia Marriott Downtown.
 
 

Philly Cooks

Congratulations to the 2010 Philly Cooks! Winners. Click here to see who won Dish of the Year, the winning dishes, event photos and more...
 
 

Philadelphia Magazine Daily

Follow Philadelphia Magazine tweets on twitter.com/phillymag
 
 

Martini Madness

Stir, Sip & Socialize at the year's most anticipated cocktail party. Don't miss the madness! March 31. National Constitution Center.